• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

The Auto Industry Created Its Own Competition. Will AI Finally Force It to Change?

Eric Damiani

Lot Lizard
Feb 16, 2015
9
2
Awards
3
First Name
Eric

The Auto Industry Created Its Own Competition. Will AI Finally Force It to Change?​

An independent perspective on automotive retailing, customer relationships, and the next wave of change​


By Eric Damiani​

AUTHOR'S DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely my own, based on my personal experiences and observations throughout my career in the automotive industry. They do not represent the views, policies, or positions of any current or former employer, dealership, automotive manufacturer, or affiliated organization.

A Question I've Been Asking Since 1999​

In 1999, while working for a General Motors dealership, I attended a meeting about GM BuyPower, the manufacturer's internet vehicle-shopping platform. The internet was beginning to transform how consumers researched products, and the automotive industry was deciding how it would participate.

I remember asking why customers couldn't simply identify exactly which dealership had the vehicle they wanted. The response I recall emphasized directing the customer to a local dealership, where the retailer could locate the vehicle and earn the sale. I understood the logic from the dealership's perspective, but it seemed unnecessarily complicated from the customer's perspective.

That question has stayed with me for more than 25 years: why does the industry so often design the shopping process around how it wants customers to buy rather than how customers actually want to shop?

How the Industry Helped Create Its Own Competition​

Third-party marketplaces recognized an opportunity to make inventory, vehicle comparisons, and pricing information easier to find. Companies such as AutoTrader, Cars.com, and CarsDirect built valuable businesses helping customers navigate a fragmented retail system.

Manufacturers and dealerships already had the vehicles and much of the underlying inventory information. Yet outside companies found ways to organize and present it more conveniently. Manufacturers have since improved their own digital tools substantially, but third-party intermediaries are now deeply established.

Dealerships pay for advertising, leads, and customer-acquisition services, sometimes only to compete for the same price-sensitive customer against several other retailers of the identical brand. The outside companies provide real value; the question is how much demand for those services was created by the industry's own complexity.

What Saturn Understood About the Experience​

Before that GM meeting, I worked for Saturn, which approached selling cars differently. Its no-haggle philosophy reduced the anxiety and uncertainty of traditional negotiation. More importantly, it allowed employees to focus on the customer.

Vehicle deliveries were celebrations. Families took photographs, employees welcomed buyers to the Saturn family, and customers seemed genuinely excited. Saturn even offered a 30-day return policy in its early years; at the dealership where I worked, I don't recall a customer returning a vehicle under it.

Saturn wasn't perfect, and its eventual disappearance shows that a distinctive retail experience alone cannot sustain an automaker. Still, it demonstrated that a different relationship with customers was possible. Its relatively protected market structure also reduced the incentive for nearby Saturn retailers to undercut one another. That was a meaningful difference from today's intense same-brand price competition.

Premium Showrooms, Discount-Driven Incentives​

Consider Mazda's efforts to build a more premium image through upgraded retail facilities and customer environments. The goal is a polished experience consistent with the product. But a customer can enjoy an excellent presentation in a beautiful showroom, then discover that another dealer 75 miles away offers the same vehicle for considerably less.

The customer may understandably choose the lower price. Meanwhile, the dealership that invested in the experience may lose the sale. This is not an argument against consumer savings. It is a question about whether the industry's incentives support the experience manufacturers say they want.

I've also witnessed the pressure of month-end sales reports, rankings, and volume targets. Unit sales are easy to measure. Long-term loyalty is harder. When manufacturers emphasize one metric most visibly, dealers naturally organize around it. You cannot consistently reward short-term volume while expecting every decision to prioritize lifetime customer relationships.

Winning the Sale but Losing the Customer​

Having worked with more than 15 dealerships, I've observed that many draw the overwhelming majority of their customers from a relatively local area. In some dealership analyses I've conducted, roughly 90 percent of business originated within about 20 miles. That is my observation from particular operations, not a claim about every dealership nationally.

So why discount aggressively to draw a customer from 50 or 100 miles away? A neighboring dealer may respond by pursuing customers from your area. Both dealers spend money and reduce margins, while the manufacturer may simply see a sale of the same brand.

The distant customer may save money, but convenience becomes an issue. A customer who drives 75 miles to buy a car is unlikely to repeat a 150-mile round trip for every service appointment. That dealer may win a transaction without winning an ongoing relationship.

Promotions such as complimentary washes, lifetime oil changes, or tire benefits make more sense when customers can actually use them conveniently. Otherwise, the benefits may be more persuasive in the showroom than useful during ownership.

The Service Relationship Is the Long-Term Opportunity​

Replacement tires illustrate the scale of the opportunity. Modern Tire Dealer reported that franchised automobile dealerships accounted for about 9.5 percent of U.S. consumer replacement tire sales in 2025. Most of that business went elsewhere.

Independent tire shops, service chains, warehouse clubs, and repair facilities compete effectively on price, convenience, and trust. Dealers should not assume they are entitled to that business. They need to earn it.

But the initial purchase experience can help establish a relationship that leads to service, tires, brakes, repeat purchases, and referrals. A dealership that focuses solely on the next sale may overlook the economics of the next five or ten years. Service retention is not merely an aftersales statistic; it can be central to customer lifetime value.

What Tesla Changed Beyond the Powertrain​

Tesla is worth studying not just as an electric-vehicle manufacturer but as a retailer. Customers can research, configure, order, and arrange delivery largely online without negotiating among independent Tesla franchisees selling the same product.

Tesla still spends money on customer acquisition, staffing, financing, delivery, and service. It also changes prices and offers incentives. Its growth cannot be attributed solely to retailing; products, technology, charging infrastructure, brand recognition, and policy incentives mattered too.

Nevertheless, Tesla demonstrated that a substantial automotive business can use a fundamentally different purchasing process. Saturn showed that no-haggle retailing could create an unusually memorable experience. Tesla showed how much of the transaction could be simplified digitally. Traditional manufacturers should examine both lessons without pretending either model is flawless.

AI Could Challenge Sales and Finance at Once​

Artificial intelligence may accelerate the shift. A customer can increasingly use AI to research vehicles, compare inventory, request out-the-door prices, evaluate interest rates, and examine optional finance-and-insurance products.

An AI assistant might contact many dealerships instead of three or four. It may also make customers more aware of outside financing alternatives and the total cost of warranties and protection products. That could place pressure on both vehicle margins and finance income, although a sustained decline in F&I profitability is not yet a demonstrated outcome.

Dealerships still need professionals to explain vehicles, manage compliance, arrange financing, process documents, and support customers. But the roles may become more advisory and less centered on negotiation. Sales managers, business development teams, and finance offices may all need to reconsider how they create value.

The more provocative question is not whether AI can negotiate a lower price. It is whether AI will make customers ask why buying a vehicle needed to be so complicated in the first place.

A One-Price Model Needs an Honest Economic Test​

Transparent, no-haggle pricing could reduce time spent negotiating, lower some staffing and lead-acquisition costs, and let employees focus on product knowledge and customer care. Those savings are possibilities, not guarantees.

There is also a serious consumer counterargument. Competition between dealers can save buyers thousands of dollars. A fixed price is not automatically a fair or competitive price. A badly designed system could make vehicles more expensive.

Manufacturers already influence advertising through various brand standards and pricing-related programs, but regulating advertised prices is legally different from dictating final transaction prices. Antitrust law, franchise statutes, and dealer agreements matter. Any reform must preserve lawful competition and consumer choice.

The goal should be competitive, clearly disclosed out-the-door pricing, not an artificial price floor. Voluntary no-haggle programs, simpler finance comparisons, and more consistent online-to-showroom experiences deserve careful testing.

Why Manufacturers Should Reconsider Their Incentives​

When one franchised dealer takes a sale from another dealer of the same brand, the manufacturer may still sell a vehicle. The retailers, however, absorb the costs of advertising, discounting, commissions, and potentially losing future service business.

That creates a potential mismatch between manufacturer volume goals and individual dealer economics. Manufacturers care about healthy dealers, but short-term metrics may not capture the cost of repeatedly exchanging customers across market boundaries.

Rather than measuring success mainly in monthly deliveries, manufacturers could give greater strategic weight to retention, repeat purchases, service satisfaction, referrals, and the total cost of acquiring and serving customers.

A Practical Way Forward​

The answer need not be eliminating dealerships. Customers still value test drives, expert explanations, trade-in assistance, convenient service, and a trusted local relationship. What they may not value is an exhausting process of repeated negotiations and inconsistent information.

Imagine an OEM-supported, legally reviewed pilot in which independent participating dealers offer transparent out-the-door prices, straightforward online ordering, competitive financing comparisons, and knowledgeable salaried product specialists. Customers could still shop where they choose. Dealers could compete through service, convenience, availability, and the quality of the ownership experience.

The pilot should be measured rigorously: acquisition cost, front-end and F&I gross profit, staffing expense, customer satisfaction, service retention, repeat purchases, and overall lifetime profitability. If the model delivers better value to customers and a sustainable business for dealers, expand it. If not, revise it.

AI itself could help dealers simplify paperwork, support employees, improve follow-up, and make service more convenient. The industry can use this technology to improve its own model rather than merely defending itself against outside shopping agents.

The Industry Needs to Reward the Experience It Says It Wants​

Looking back, I keep returning to the question I asked in 1999: why not give customers the information they are looking for?

Saturn demonstrated the value of a less adversarial purchase. Third-party marketplaces showed the demand for accessible information. Tesla challenged assumptions about the retail process. AI may now give customers unprecedented power to compare and complete transactions.

The automotive industry has made tremendous progress, but some of its traditional practices continue to create expense and friction. Manufacturers say they want satisfaction, loyalty, and lasting relationships. Perhaps it is time to design incentives and a purchasing process that consistently reward those outcomes.

The automotive industry has spent decades defending the traditional process of selling cars. Its future may depend on being willing to redesign that process before someone else does it for them.


Eric Damiani

Automotive Industry Professional | Over 25 Years of Experience in Automotive Retailing, Sales, and Marketing



Sources and verification notes​

  • Modern Tire Dealer, 2026 Facts Issue (2025 U.S. replacement tire channel share).
  • Mazda North American Operations, Retail Evolution program announcements.
  • Cox Automotive, Car Buyer Journey and service-retention research.
  • Tesla annual vehicle delivery releases and public ordering information.
  • Historical Saturn and GM BuyPower observations are the author's personal recollections.
 

✨ AI Highlights

Eric Damiani, an automotive industry veteran, argues that the industry has long undermined its own customer relationships through opaque pricing, adversarial sales tactics, and self-created digital middlemen — and that AI may finally force dealerships to confront these structural problems or be bypassed entirely. Drawing on experiences dating back to GM's 1999 BuyPower initiative, he traces how dealers repeatedly had opportunities to embrace transparency and customer-centric retailing but chose short-term friction over long-term trust. The central insight is that AI-powered tools could empower consumers to bypass traditional dealership touchpoints altogether, making the industry's historical resistance to change an existential threat rather than a manageable inconvenience.

Replies Views 0 81 Started Last Reply