• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

Small dealer - back behind the wall. Need high ROI marketing spend?

Jun 29, 2024
1
1
Awards
2
First Name
Michael
Good morning, everyone,

I am a small dealer whose back is behind the wall. I have limited cash to spend on digital marketing and am essentially living paycheck to paycheck as a dealer. I have finally got ahold as to how to do this game and am now selling 2-3 cars a month, now I wanted to see if I could scale to do this game to get ahead of the many mistakes that have set me behind financially. I do have a floorplan and cash for reconditioning, but the majority of vehicles I buy do not require much at all.

I sell quality vehicles, that are I buy at relatively good prices. I just wanted to know what marketing spend wouldgive me greatest return on investment.

I am in Tampa Florida, have been offered an offer from CarFax at $1248/month with two free months.

Thoughts on CarFax? Other third party listing sites worth it?
Any recommendations?
Meta ads? Let me know, thank you :)

Right now I just use facebook marketplace
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron Weston
If you want to try some Meta Ads I can set you up with an easy way to post your inventory and you can try a small spend and see if you're happy with the results? We have seen good results on that side with used vehicles, but typically takes 1-2 weeks to completely warm up and start delivering to the "right" customers using the Meta AI stuff.

Shoot me a message if you want to try it out and I'll set you up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron Weston
Good morning, everyone,

I am a small dealer whose back is behind the wall. I have limited cash to spend on digital marketing and am essentially living paycheck to paycheck as a dealer. I have finally got ahold as to how to do this game and am now selling 2-3 cars a month, now I wanted to see if I could scale to do this game to get ahead of the many mistakes that have set me behind financially. I do have a floorplan and cash for reconditioning, but the majority of vehicles I buy do not require much at all.

I sell quality vehicles, that are I buy at relatively good prices. I just wanted to know what marketing spend wouldgive me greatest return on investment.

I am in Tampa Florida, have been offered an offer from CarFax at $1248/month with two free months.

Thoughts on CarFax? Other third party listing sites worth it?
Any recommendations?
Meta ads? Let me know, thank you :)

Right now I just use facebook marketplace
Hey, just wanted to say good on you for getting to 2-3 cars a month. Sounds like you made some progress and traction! Some thoughts from me as someone who spent 5 years building dealer marketing software.

I would:

1. Do the math on the CarFax. At $1248 a month across 2-3 sales is about $400-600 per car. Take the 2 free months only if you can cleanly cancel and ask about auto-renew. Track the leads IT SENDS! If it's not adding 2 or more deals by month 2, I would cancel it as it's not worth it.

2. Max out FB marketplace first like others are saying. Post 20 or more photos plus a 30 second walkaround video for each car. Renew listings every few days. Also answer messages within 5 minutes (Buyers usually go with whatever dealer answers first).

3. Free channels (FREE BEFORE AD SPEND!!): Fill out your Google Business Profile and ask every buyer for a review. Then add OfferUp and Craigslist.
4. Referrals: Offer past buyers $100-200 for each referral that buys. That’s the cheapest cost per car you’ll find.

5. Track it: Keep a simple sheet with each lead’s source, whether they bought, and what you spent. After 60 days you’ll know where to put your next dollar.

Skip Meta ads until you can answer leads fast. Paid leads go cold quickly.


ALSO!!! Please DM if you have questions or need help. Cheers.
 
At 2–3 cars a month, I'd be careful about committing $1,248 a month before knowing what it's going to produce. First I'd look at the people who have already raised their hand. Work your unsold leads and showroom traffic from the last 90 days. Call your sold customers, check on them, and ask for referrals when appropriate. Before buying more advertising, make sure you're working the opportunities you already have. If you test a paid listing, measure cost per car sold, not just cost per lead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron Weston
Good morning, everyone,

I am a small dealer whose back is behind the wall. I have limited cash to spend on digital marketing and am essentially living paycheck to paycheck as a dealer. I have finally got ahold as to how to do this game and am now selling 2-3 cars a month, now I wanted to see if I could scale to do this game to get ahead of the many mistakes that have set me behind financially. I do have a floorplan and cash for reconditioning, but the majority of vehicles I buy do not require much at all.

I sell quality vehicles, that are I buy at relatively good prices. I just wanted to know what marketing spend wouldgive me greatest return on investment.

I am in Tampa Florida, have been offered an offer from CarFax at $1248/month with two free months.

Thoughts on CarFax? Other third party listing sites worth it?
Any recommendations?
Meta ads? Let me know, thank you :)
Managing tight budgets and calculating real ROI on every dollar spent takes discipline—much like weighing risks and checking competitive value on platforms such as Vivatbet when making calculated calls during the weekend games. https://vivatbet.ie/en/line/water-polo
Right now I just use facebook marketplace
If you are currently moving 2–3 units a month with limited cash flow, committing to a $1,248/month CarFax contract right away can put heavy pressure on your margins—instead, double down on optimizing your Google Business Profile for local Tampa searches and run tightly geo-targeted Meta Lead Ads featuring clean walkaround videos of your reconditioned inventory. Once your cash flow stabilizes and you need consistent third-party buyer intent, lower-cost listing aggregators like CarGurus or Autotrader often deliver a faster cost-per-sale return for independent lots than expensive fixed monthly packages.
 
At 2-3 cars a month id keep marketplace as your base and test google a bit before signing $1,248/mo for a listing package
  1. VLAs (vehicle listing ads). Pay per click on the actual car w/ photo, price, miles. Needs a vehicle feed in merchant center, most website providers can push one. Start around $20/day
  2. Make sure your photos are fantastic. On VLAs and marketplace the photo is what gets the click
  3. Get a tracking number + UTMs on every channel before you spend anything. In 60 days you’ll know cost per sold car not just cost per lead
 
  • Like
Reactions: ryan.leslie

✨ AI Highlights

A cash-strapped small dealer in Tampa selling 2-3 cars a month asks whether a $1,248/month CarFax listing is worth it and what digital marketing channels offer the best ROI at limited spend. Respondents largely steered him away from CarFax at that price point, recommending free Facebook Marketplace, low-cost Craigslist posts, and Meta ads as higher-ROI starting points. A key insight from the thread is to exhaust existing leads, sold customers, and referrals before committing to paid advertising, and to measure cost per car sold rather than cost per lead.

Replies Views 6 532 Started Last Reply