Garage? What's that? (Condo living has me with just one parking spot and no garage whatsoever. It's about the only reason I'd consider a house, though.)
Currently parked in my spot is a slightly-dented (grumble) 2009 Pontiac Vibe 2.4L. Just broke 35,000 miles (20,000 of them mine), and still doing strong overall. If I had to replace it today, I'd probably be stuck between an HHR or a Terrain unless GMC greenlit the Granite concept. Once you go wagon (which I did with a 1997 Honda CR-V--close enough!), it's hard to go back.