Jason, please don't take offense if I come off as blunt.
On your new. Have your MSRP, then your Paul Barnett price (with the rebate out of it). You can show a Paul Barnett Discount also, if you chose. This is what I mean by perceived value.
Somebody has access to the backend tool to that website. There has to be somebody to call. I hate how you get a menu when you click on new or used inventory. It should bring you to the cars and not a menu.
You are on the right track but your customer doesn't know what the market is for the car. Show them the "market value", "retail value" or whatever. Then have your "Special Internet Price". Have a call to action in your description. "At this price, this one won't last long" "Call now" or "We can't keep these in stock" "Call now to check availability".We do not have any incentive other than hoping a fair market price will generate a little action.
On your new. Have your MSRP, then your Paul Barnett price (with the rebate out of it). You can show a Paul Barnett Discount also, if you chose. This is what I mean by perceived value.
Somebody has access to the backend tool to that website. There has to be somebody to call. I hate how you get a menu when you click on new or used inventory. It should bring you to the cars and not a menu.