1. Definitely phone leads.
2. Spend $2,000 on PPC - I like instant gratification, especially if you put money on keywords that convert the best. SEO is important, but I think most of us who read this blog are constantly optimizing our sites by creating relevant content and keywords that are appreciated by consumers and indexed by search engines.
3. “your price is too high” Can't sell what you don't have.
4. Have no form at all - lack of response is a buzz kill for converting first time unique visitors into returning visitors and getting bookmarked. If you're gonna spend money on service PPC campaigns to drive customers to your website, you better answer their online request. If they put out the effort of giving their real name and a valid phone number/email, they deserve an immediate response. Otherwise, delete the form and convert to a phone lead.
5. Have a negative consumer review directly under you - curious customers will still click on your weblink. Bad press is better than no press. Negative reviews give more attention to you than your competition dominating the SERPS. How many people are aware of Husker BMW now? The great thing about feedback, positive or negative, is that you can respond to it, blog about it, refute it, YouTube it, provide "happy customer" testimontials to counteract it, and use it as a launch pad for even more press.
6. Have a payplan that pays out for previous Internet customers - the internet has changed owner loyalty and it's important that we don't forget about the customer after the first sale. We spend all this time trying to buy leads from third parties, optimize our websites, implement SEM, just to get new prospects. We should spend at least half the time we do on current customers as we do prospecting. These customers can be a huge referral base, regardless of geography. We should get back the investment we put into advertising so hard to acquire the "internet" customer in the first place!
7. Remove all the email forms from your site and rely only on the phone numbers. PHONE LEADS rock! The biggest challenge of our bdc is getting customers to give us their phone number. It takes a lot of effort - we average between 5 and 10 emails back and forth to a customer - before they finally give in and share their phone #. How many of you get ebay local "best offers" on a car, and all you have is their ebay id? ? No phone number, no email address, no customer name. How much time is wasted trying to respond to these leads? In "internet lead triage," the ones with phone numbers are always treated first.
8. Have your mail server blacklisted. Their are tons or legit, whitelisted email marketing firms out there who are happy to host your email marketing campaigns. Losing your domain name or getting blacklisted by the search engines is sure death for a website and it can take years to get back into Page 1 of SERPS.