• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

vAuto Replacement

Curious as well.

I've felt for a while now VAuto is missing/hiding sales and current inventory data. Haven't had the time to prove it out but the correlation between wholesale and retail pricing suggests some are looking at a different picture than just VAuto. (Fully understanding VAuto isn't the end-all solution for pricing and acquisition)

My guess, ACV is pulling in their own internal auction data on top of MMR. The big question is where the sold data and current listings are coming from?
Also Vauto does not know when or for what amount any vehicle sold for, they see it fall offline and take the last listed price as the selling price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ryan Everson
Maxdigital could not provide a demo link. But to be honest he had a struggle using/showing it to us. Blamed his internet connection.

I’d say the MAX demo was one of the worst ones. Theg had many issues getting through the whole thing. Reports were like very blah. Just spits out white excel spreadsheets. They have signed up many large dealer groups (maybe they got some volume discount). I’d think that would be a rough go if you signed up for that one. He actually apologized to me via email because he said it wasn’t his best demo.

I still tried to judge it based on what was there. Not much IMO.. I saw enough.

Then with VINCUE there is a ton of information but the layout is super busy and missing some crucial pricing elements to make decisions.

But my big thing was reports and being able to price fast and efficiently. If you price your inventory once a week or whatever the case. A lot of these websites are built on some janky code base. So the demo does not do you justice. It’s like me showing you pictures of a car but not letting you drive it.

VAuto was fine before we switched to Dealerslink; I did sacrifice a couple things. But I wanted to ditch COX automotive solutions. They think they have all the “data”; but at the end of the day we own our data; it’s our commodity to control. What we gained was speed and my ability to price 100 cars in one click if I wanted to. Nobody has that. VAuto I would have to open up 20 tabs and wait. Price them all, close them out, one by one. Now I got more of my time back.
Hey Jeff,

I know this post was from over a year ago... but VINCUE listened to the feedback. We revamped the layout at the beginning of the year based on feedback like yours and it looks exceptionally different... specifically in reporting and during the appraisals themselves.

If you ever want to take another look, let me know.

~JR
VINCUE
202-664-3630
 
Last edited:
Full disclosure, I'm the founder of AutoVue, so take this with that in mind. A few things I'd check on any vAuto replacement, based on what people said here:

1. Comp coverage. Pull 10 of your cars and compare the comp count side by side at your usual radius. A few people above found 10-15 missing comps, which skews every price.
2. Bulk repricing speed. Time how long it takes to reprice the whole lot.
3. Data ownership. Ask in writing if you can export your pricing history when you leave.
4. Contract and add-ons. Get the all-in monthly number, not the base price.

AutoVue is built for independents and smaller stores. It does a daily stocking plan, appraisals and pricing on autopilot within limits you set, starting at $399/mo with no contract. Happy to run it on anyone's inventory if you want a side-by-side.
 
Last edited:

✨ AI Highlights

A dealer asks for opinions on ACV MAX (formerly Max Digital) as a vAuto replacement, sparking a broader conversation about the accuracy of vAuto's sold data, where competing tools source their market intelligence, and which alternatives are worth exploring. Key concerns raised include vAuto's method of estimating sale prices from last-listed prices rather than actual transaction data, with the original poster ultimately choosing VinCue after six months, while others recommend Carketa and AutoVue as lower-cost options.

Replies Views 47 25,806 Started Last Reply