• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

Best "Value Your Trade" platform?

As an added benefit, if you have TIM, it is fully and seamlessly integrated into the vAuto appraisal module. <end of shameless plug> :)

Yes, but as I've said before and will say over and over, TIM has no business being on your dealership website for lead generation. I would have it on a hidden page accessible by direct link only.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stefan
@Jeff Kershner -- what timing to bring up an old thread!

I just saw a demo for http://www.eautoappraise.com/ - and man was I impressed.

A few points I liked:

1. Credit Miner - soft credit pulls -- SEAMLESS for the consumer! And, you as a dealer get more information to help close the lead on an appointment!

2. Facebook - No need to fill in the form for the customer ... if you want they can use your Facebook account to prefill it in. Didn't I see a post from Jeff on this?

3. NO Branding -- no kbb, no blackbook, no nada, no edmunds, no purecars, etc... -- NO branding... making it look more like a dealer appraisel!

4. You can control the over/under for values down to the make/model. (Did I say you need "hope for gain?")

5. Customer photo and video uploads!

6. End of process special offers -- making your offer stand out...with a video, coupon, or ?? -- looks like you can be pretty creative!
 
@DrewAment I just sat through a demo of TradePending - simplistic without all the hoopla that no one uses anyways, like...

5. Customer photo and video uploads! I was using a service awhile ago that offered this. I even pushed the feature when and where I could. Not 1 person ever used it. It's easier to ask the person to text you the photos from their phone.

4. You can control the over/under for values down to the make/model - hows that for transparency?

3. NO Branding -- no kbb, no blackbook, no nada, no edmunds, no purecars, etc... -- NO branding... making it look more like a dealer appraisal! - That's debatable 3rd party is GOOD, 3rd Party is BAD! Which is it?

2. Facebook - No need to fill in the form for the customer ... if you want they can use your Facebook account to prefill it in. Didn't I see a post from Jeff on this? Facebook is testing / evolving the traditional form fill process, but only within the facebook environment

What's the purpose of the trade-in form anyways?

1. To provide the shopper a great experience and an easy 1,2,3 step evaluation on the value of their vehicle (that they will never be satisfied with)?

2. Convert into a form fill lead?
 
Outside of the US there are a number of providers that are doing trade-in appraisal booths.
North America is standing still on this one, but I think the biggest disruption will be when Jiffy Lube puts in a vehicle appraisal system.
I think consumers can be trained to appraise their vehicle offline, rather than filling out a form / uploading photos to a single dealer.
 
Whichever provider you use, I would find out what your form abandon rate is, since in the end you are both trying to give the shopper an approximate number, but more importantly capture a hand-raiser. If your trade in tool is more like an appraisal interrogation, you’re likely seeing a 20% or more form-abandon rate, frustrating consumers and missing opportunities.
 
Whichever provider you use, I would find out what your form abandon rate is, since in the end you are both trying to give the shopper an approximate number, but more importantly capture a hand-raiser. If your trade in tool is more like an appraisal interrogation, you’re likely seeing a 20% or more form-abandon rate, frustrating consumers and missing opportunities.

This is absolutely a topic we plan to tackle on today's show at 1:00 PM EST. The sad part about what you're saying @georgenenni is that most dealers employ an "appraisal interrogation" plugin.

Hopefully we can at least open some eyes today.

Here's the recording:

 

Attachments

  • June-27-Brice-Englert-TradePending.png
    June-27-Brice-Englert-TradePending.png
    774.1 KB · Views: 0
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: George Nenni

✨ AI Highlights

Dealers compare trade-in valuation tools (Black Book, AutoTrader TIM, PureCars, Edmunds, and Accu-Price) to find the best balance of user interface, lead quality, and cost. While opinions vary by market and dealership setup, the consensus is that no single tool is objectively "best"—success depends more on salesperson training, realistic valuations that offer customers "hope for gain," and ultimately converting inquiries into in-store appointments rather than the platform itself.

Replies Views 19 13,824 Started Last Reply