• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

BREAKING news! Carvana & Vroom is bleeding cash. Is Ecommerce in auto DOA?

Carvana napkin math...

Carvana employs ~20,8000 employees and sold 425,237 cars last year.

425,237 cars
÷ 20,800 employees
----------
20 cars sold annually per employee
÷ 12 months
----------
= 1.7 cars sold monthly per employee

1.7 cars per month? Suddenly our 5 car Freds look pretty good!

Thought provoking stuff Ryan. I ran CVNA vs AN...
1654781429116.png
Carvana's head count p/sale isn't that far off vs Traditional Retailers (like AN), yet, CVNA's PVR is astonishingly high and they're bleeding cash with no end in sight. When the UC bubble ends and -if- the market shifts to a buyers market, CVNA's challenges to turn a profit will get 100x more difficult.

CVNA's perfect storm is coming and they know it. I'm looking for CVNA to pivot.

p.s. hi everyone!!
p.p.s. not sure if unit counts incl wholesale for either one
 
p.s. hi everyone!!
5955f152dd550358b807372ec23a45be.gif
 

✨ AI Highlights

Automotive professionals debate whether the failures of e-commerce car retailers like Carvana and Vroom signal the death of online auto sales, with most concluding the business model itself was fundamentally flawed rather than the channel. Key criticisms center on unsustainable customer acquisition costs (both for inventory and buyers), failure to address that consumers want to inspect vehicles in person, and underestimation of the advantages existing dealers possess (brand loyalty, service relationships, trade-in inventory). The emerging consensus is that e-commerce will succeed in auto retail only when integrated into traditional dealerships' operations rather than attempted as a standalone, capital-intensive business.

Replies Views 219 124,156 Started Last Reply