-
This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →
Autotrader — DealerRefresh Vendor Library
About suggest a correction →
Online automotive marketplace and advertising platform connecting car shoppers with dealership inventory listings.
Community evidence → Stable
Autotrader has 242 mentions across 20+ years of DealerRefresh dealer discussion — rated 14% · Criticized. The community includes 11 positive and 67 negative takes.
242 mentions · 11 positive · 67 negative · Scored from 20+ years of candid DealerRefresh discussion. Scores shift as new conversations happen.
NEGATIVE
"Ford CPO inventory listings managed through AutoTrader and planned expansion to Cars.com, CarGurus, Carfax, and KBB. Additionally, the new Ford Blue Advantage website (hosted by AutoTrader) is generating minimal organic search visibility and referral traffic to dealer sites"
Are you hearing of Ford's new CPO program, certifying non-Ford vehicles? →
NEGATIVE
"A dealer proposes that NADA/NIADA launch their own online inventory marketplace to compete with Autotrader and CarGurus"
NADA & NIADA - An Idea to Help You, Us, and Consumers! →
NEGATIVE
"the store underutilizes major listing platforms like AutoTrader and Cars.com, suggesting management resistance to real market competition"
New here →
NEGATIVE
"platform implementation decisions are entirely up to Cars.com and AutoTrader, not technical limitations, suggesting dealers could see significant chat volume increases if these platforms prioritized visibility and proactive features"
Cars.com chat - anyone seeing anything? →
NEGATIVE
"viral content and word-of-mouth rather than paid advertising platforms like Google Ads or Autotrader, claiming to spend virtually nothing on marketing"
Ling's Magical ***CAR MARKETING IDEAS IN THE UK, THROUGH THE VIRUS NOISE *** →
NEGATIVE
"Craigslist sends significant traffic, the quality is poor (high bounce rates and low engagement) compared to other sources"
Traffic Sources? →
NEGATIVE
"pricing complaints dealers already have about Autotrader and Cars.com"
Think Before You Sign - Third Party Lead Providers →
NEGATIVE
"violates policies on major listing platforms like AutoTrader and Cars.com"
What do you think of this? →
NEGATIVE
"competitors like Autotrader and KBB offer similar linking for free"
Cars.com linking to Dealers website VDP. Is this New??? →
NEGATIVE
"CARFAX's exclusive partnerships with AutoTrader and Cars.com create a marketing disadvantage for competitors—the real 'extortion' mechanism"
OPINION: CARFAX is extorting my dealership →
NEGATIVE
"A dealer received a lead from AutoTrader that turned out to be from autopitch.com, a middleman service that posts dealer offers on their website and charges a $150 referral fee (deducted from the dealer's offered price) if a customer they represent makes a purchase."
autopitch.com →
NEGATIVE
"ComplyAuto's approach puts independent dealers at a disadvantage compared to major competitors (Autotrader, CarGurus, Edmunds) and large corporations that don't display consent popups"
Auto Comply update to Cookie Consent →
NEGATIVE
"A South Carolina dealer seeks recommendations for new lead sources beyond Cars.com and Autotrader"
Lead Sources currently looking for a good one →
NEGATIVE
"third-party leads (Autotrader, Cars.com) typically ranging from 6-20%... while third-party sources may show acceptable close rates, their ROI is often poor compared to investing in driving traffic directly to dealership websites"
Percentages on leads →
NEGATIVE
"A follow-up comment criticizes AutoTrader for not updating its employees' software after an IE7-related security incident on DealerRefresh, questioning why any company would allow outdated browser use."
IE7 Tax for using Website →
NEGATIVE
"Then when I was at a Dealer Advisory Board for AutoTrader I ran into one of the co-owners; Adam Simms."
Responselogix →
MIXED
"Dealers acknowledge its broad market reach and integration with tools like KBB and vAuto, but recurring concerns center on lead quality, rising costs, and the bundled pricing pressure that comes with being part of the larger Cox ecosystem."
Community Review: Autotrader →
MIXED
"AutoTrader's official representative confirmed the practice violates their best practices guidelines and committed to having a district sales manager address it with the offending dealer. The thread concluded positively, with participants praising AutoTrader for taking swift action"
Autotrader Fraud? →
MIXED
"Dealers debate whether Autotrader's default high-to-low price sorting is a manipulative tactic to boost page views and ad revenue, or a legitimate algorithm choice that maximizes shopper exposure to all inventory."
Does Autotrader think we're all oblivious? →
MIXED
"Dealers debating whether to boycott third-party classified sites like AutoTrader and Cars.com are stuck in outdated thinking—these platforms now control significant market reach and dealers who don't participate lose competitive advantage to those who do."
Boycott the Third Party Sites like it's 2010! →
MIXED
"Dealers discuss AutoTrader's new "BOB" (Big Orange Button) feature—a prominent call-to-action that directs consumers from AutoTrader vehicle listings to dealership websites—and share mixed results on its impact to their business metrics. The thread reveals that some dealers saw measurable improvements in website traffic after implementing BOB in early 2011, though others expressed reluctance to share detailed performance data, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions about ROI."
AutoTrader.com BOB - What Has BOB Done for You? →
MIXED
"A respondent identifies it as likely AutoTrader's Trade-in Marketplace and shares that while the tool was effective and benefited from AutoTrader's trusted brand name, appraisal values tended to run low and adoption varied depending on how dealers and salespeople utilized it."
What your opinion on this new car sourcing service? →
MIXED
"AutoTrader's acquisition of VinSolutions and whether consolidation in the dealer software space is harmful to the industry... point to examples like AutoTrader's hands-off management of VAuto as evidence that acquired companies can maintain their independence and growth trajectory"
Autotrader acquires Vinsolutions →
MIXED
"third-party marketplaces (Autotrader, CarGurus, etc.) running Google VLA ads on their inventory is beneficial or harmful"
"Why are third parties running Google VLA ads on MY vehicles? Shut it down!" →
MIXED
"AutoTrader announced that dealers can now choose between Carfax or AutoCheck vehicle history reports starting September 1st, ending Carfax's exclusive partnership."
AutoTrader Customers can now use CarFax OR AutoCheck now →
MIXED
"questioning whether to cancel AutoTrader questions their ROI after tracking only 2-5 sales per month from the platform, but forum respondents overwhelmingly suggest the real problem is poor lead sourcing discipline among sales staff rather than AutoTrader's effectiveness"
Should We Drop AutoTrader? →
MIXED
"Forum members discuss why many dealerships underutilize AutoTrader's premium features like Dynamic Display ads, Spotlights, and special offers despite having paid placements. The consensus identifies time constraints and staffing limitations as the primary barriers—one moderator notes she's the sole person managing AutoTrader tasks and often works off the clock—though the original poster argues it's worth the effort, having successfully cleared 2011 inventory through spotlighted offers"
AutoTrader Display Ads, Special offers and Spotlights →
MIXED
"questions whether Autotrader's $800-900 cost-per-sale justifies its 1/3 of their e-commerce budget, prompting debate about the platform's true value versus alternatives like Cars.com. Responses are mixed: some dealers have abandoned Autotrader entirely, others defend it as part of a multi-touch customer journey"
Autotrader - Good, but $800-900/sale good???? →
✏ Request an edit
See something wrong? We review all requests and apply corrections after staff review. No login required.
Corrections go to a review queue. Staff apply them after verification. Your IP address is hashed and stored to prevent spam.