What are the best lead sources for ya'll for internet leads? How is Cars.com and AutoTrader performing?
in the Jurassic era when Skroob was still retailing (also when I first met him
) Cars was definitely for the pinky in the air types. I'm in Maryland in the heart of the competitive DMV madness and I see most dealers locked-in/strong-armed/stuck-with/have-to be with Autotrader and Cargurus who battle for 1st and 2nd and Cars.com comes in 3rd.Dealers are debating which third-party lead sources deliver the best ROI, with shared Q3 close rate data showing AutoTrader leading at 9.4% and TrueCar trailing at 3.8%. The thread quickly moves beyond raw close rates to expose deeper issues: single-source CRM attribution inflates certain platforms' numbers (AutoTrader benefits from alphabetical drop-down ordering), third-party sites increasingly buy paid traffic using dealers' own inventory to outbid them on Google, and multi-touch attribution tools like Clarivoy suggest much of the real value from these platforms is upstream exposure rather than direct leads. The key takeaway is that evaluating third-party providers on lead count or close rate alone is misleading—dealers should measure total cost per sale, gross per copy, and DMS-matched results while accounting for attribution flaws.