Matt,
Please don't take this the wrong way, but I would like to discuss these websites and see what others think in regards to my comments. I am no website expert by any means, but I do know what I like and dislike.
Jerry,
Great design must produce ROI and that's not seen by the naked eye. How can you form an opinion without knowing the score???
We've had this talk before, You're a well ranked golfer, should I be giving YOU golf swing and game management opinions? ... NOT! You were a master chess player! Does my opinions on how to win at chess important to you? NOT!! You were a highly accomplished and competitive water skier, can my arm chair QB opinions help you, a champion water skier, win more events? NOT.
Opinions are like a**hol*s, everyone has one. Just because you have one does not mean yours has value. Opinions matter when you have a few thousand hours in effort to back them up.
The REAL game in design is all about producing conversions.
Just like in Golf or Chess, opinions in design (that really matter) come from players that invested the thousands of hours into design and are FORCED to produce MORE conversions. To get there, a designer has to totally know our industry and has deep dived into shopper needs analysis 1st. From there a designer creates several layout designs 2nd, then the designer creates A/B studies of these layouts and then
multivariate testing to optimize call to action triggers for maximum user interaction.
Many think that great page design is simply inspiration and a creative eye. No... that is simply the 1st swing on the 1st tee of a 3 day 72hole tournament.
Design is my passion, so I get a bit worked up, Sorry about the 'rant.