• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

500,000+ Dealership Calls Later: Here’s What We’re Learning About AI

John, I’d say the biggest issue is the handoff after an after-hours sales call.

If somebody calls about a specific VIN, I want the BDC to know which car they asked about, what they were looking for, and who’s responsible for following up when we open. If that unit’s gone, they need to know what alternatives were discussed too.

Otherwise, we’re making the customer start all over again.

Are you tracking how many of those AI-set appointments actually show and turn into sold deals? That’s the number I’d be interested in seeing.

VehicleLyfe Release Notes

Login to view embedded media
Group Report numbers across a dealer group The reports can now answer for a whole dealer group, not just one store at a time. Each store's numbers in the group view come from the same calculations as its own Engagement and Loyalty reports, so the stores and the group always agree. Group totals add up counts and dollars and recalculate percentages from those sums instead of averaging them. The dealer-facing page that shows these numbers ships as a separate story.

Share from the customer page Share is now on the customer page, alongside the other actions on a customer. From it, a dealer can grab the VehicleLyfe link for that customer — Home, Buy or sell, Schedule service, or Warranty — or send the vehicle straight to the CRM as a lead. Both already live on the Customer List. This puts them where a dealer is already working the customer, so no round-trip back to the list.

Trade Paths polish A pile of fixes on Trade Paths. If a car value times out while the customer is viewing a quote, the page no longer silently saves an empty number as if it were confirmed; the customer sees a Couldn't get your car value right now message with a Try again button, and the vehicle is not marked confirmed. A previous value is only reused when the car is the same and the value is still fresh for that rooftop. Home becomes Back when Trade Paths was opened from Buy or Sell, each rail shows its position as a count, the next card peeks in on phones, and the estimated payoff tile is cleaned up.

Full notes and screenshots: What's New: Group Reports

Is this broken? (Roadster Digital Retail)

Does this make you shit your pants or does it make you say... yeah, that's normal?

Yo Mitch, wazzz up! Here we go :unclejoe:

Generally speaking, most dealerships close less than one percent of the people who visited the VDP (easy math in GA4). It looks like about a tenth of one percent placed a Roadster order.

Many forces are at play.

First, from first principles, for a shopper to go from a VDP view to placing a Roadster order requires super-high conviction and the tenacity to complete all the forms. This makes for an ultra rare shopper profile (like about a tenth of one percent lol!) .

My instinct is that the Roadster orders are B‑backs, people who have been to the store, sat in the car, made a decision, and bought the car in their pajamas via Roadster.

Looking at your chart, all I see is a lot of keystroke time. What is Roadster’s role here? Does your BDC and your shopper jointly share all of the surfaces on your chart?

Car shoppers don’t want e‑commerce; they want collaborative commerce.
We, as an industry, have undervalued the complexity of car shopping. Add to this, OUR WEBSITES SUCK... Shoppers want to be 'walked thru' the process. For example, if you remove Carvana’s BDC, its sales would plummet. Carvana operates as a roofless dealership with a massive call center. Shoppers want to be hand‑led through the ornate number of forms.

May I suggest you shop carvana and shadow the process?
Go through a Carvana purchase yourself, or shadow someone and watch the machine work. It’s quite stunning, and I know that because when I see a carvana lic. plate, I speak with buyers about their experience. Most of them are drinking the Carvana koolaide. Do it, it's easy to reverse‑engineer how Carvana works.

LASTLY...
Part 1: Look at the distance of the roadster sale. My gut sqays it's Likely > than your avg sale distance.
Part 2: Invert your table and work backwards from the Roadster lead, to tools used (trade/finance) etc. I bet the Roadster users use all of the tools.

Is this broken? (Roadster Digital Retail)

Hey All,

I want to get your take and opinions on the data below. It has a swan dive, bounce, skid profile to it that makes me feel like it could be better...

I don't know what to do about it though. It's Roadsters fault, the tool has too much friction. It's our fault, our settings are the problem. It's a blend of both or maybe neither or something else.

Heck, maybe these results are outstanding for a Hyundai dealership in Canada running roadster.

If it matters we do not have the lead gate turned on in order to use the tool...

Does this make you shit your pants or does it make you say... yeah, that's normal?

1794876418622.png

How fast are you answering internet leads after 7 PM?

10DLC setup compliance should be automatically handled by the tech company you are using for the campaign. If not, RUN. As someone in the business, I can tell you we get random audits and need to prove everything is compliant. Campaign name, business name, website URL all need to properly match when setting up the campaign to avoid inbox filtering problems.

Even if you have an auto reply designed for off hours, it needs to be more intuitive than a generic "we got your request". I.E. <Name>, A specialist at <Dealer_Name> will be in touch to discuss your <Reason>. Check out our current inventory specials <URL>. We look forward to helping you find the best vehicle that fits your needs. Thank you, <Name>.

A simple customized message gives you the time for an after hours person to respond and gives the shopper some additional info and links to shop. Is that a perfect solution, no. It's still better than being generic.

Would you use a DMS that runs on a tiny box at your dealership?

The box is boss! I think all mom and pops and some smaller groups should look into this scenario. The hardware costs are minimal. If you truly airgap the system even better. Start with the problems used car dealer face. Solve them and show them how easy it is to use. Rouge Ai powered by quantum chips could take a bite of of the cloud and ASP solutions.

Small dealer - back behind the wall. Need high ROI marketing spend?

If you want to try some Meta Ads I can set you up with an easy way to post your inventory and you can try a small spend and see if you're happy with the results? We have seen good results on that side with used vehicles, but typically takes 1-2 weeks to completely warm up and start delivering to the "right" customers using the Meta AI stuff.

Shoot me a message if you want to try it out and I'll set you up.

MCP from CDK & Reynolds and other DMS companies

Good thread. Alex, I’m not convinced CDK and Reynolds will both ship something with “MCP” on the box inside 12 months. I think a few vendors will do something, and I’ve already seen some examples. Either way, this is about giving dealers more power to use their own data. Using it well at the store level will take a mindset and skill shift.

If you’re on CDK, you don’t have to wait for it. I’ve built this myself at my two stores using CDK’s Data Your Way Import/Export API. It already gives you record-level read and writeback across Service, Vehicle, Customer, Parts, and Accounting. I’ve built an MCP server and a CLI on top of that same data access. In practice, I just point my Claude or OpenAI session at the CLI, and it uses the tools to answer questions across the data sets.

To Todd’s point: we’re working from our DMS, the system of record where the deals, ROs, and accounting actually get closed every month, so the data is pretty clean. The next step is building our own internal apps, which become another source of context for the agent.

Best lead sources today for internet leads

Colin, I’d keep AutoTrader and CarGurus in the conversation, but I’d be careful calling either one the winner based on lead count or closing percentage alone.

I went back through some of our dealership lead-source reports recently. In one period, two marketplaces were credited with the same number of sold deals, but the gross per copy was nowhere close. In another, a lot of the inquiries were concentrated on just a handful of lower-priced used VINs. That’s as much a stocking and pricing conversation as it is a lead-provider conversation.

If I’m reviewing the next renewal, I want to see the actual monthly bill against unique shoppers, shown appointments, DMS-matched sold units, and gross per copy. Break new and used apart, then look at the used side by price band and VIN. A stack of leads on one aggressively priced Jeep might represent different shoppers, but we still only have one Jeep to sell.

Erick makes a fair point about customers shopping several sites before they ever call or show up. That influence matters. But showing up somewhere in the shopping journey doesn’t automatically prove an additional sale, either. And whatever source the salesperson selects in the CRM isn’t necessarily the whole story.

For me, the real question is which providers are helping us retail the right inventory at a cost that pencils, not just which one sends the most leads.
  • Like
Reactions: dealerzone

How to be a respectful vendor

Nico, since you asked for an example, here’s what would get my attention from the used-car side: a two-VIN buy sheet instead of a pitch deck.

Pick two actual vehicles that make sense for that store’s stocking mix. Show the VIN, trim and equipment, miles, seller’s asking price, location, and what you know about the title and condition. Then break down estimated transportation, recon, your fee, and where the store would realistically land in the car compared with similar units retailing in that market.

The key is separating what you’ve verified from what you’re estimating. A seller saying a car has a clean title isn’t the same as verifying it. And just because something is advertised below market doesn’t mean there’s enough room left after recon to make it a good buy.

That’s information a used-car manager can actually work with. If the numbers make sense, it’s worth pursuing an appraisal. If they don’t, telling me that upfront is valuable too. You may have just saved me time chasing a car that was never going to pencil.

I’d also find out who actually handles acquisitions at that rooftop before walking in. Some stores have the used-car manager buying, others run it through the GM or a central buyer. Get one useful example in front of the right person and let them decide if it’s in their buy box.

That’s the kind of approach I’d respect. You’re doing some of the homework before asking the dealership for its time, and you’re helping somebody make a buying decision instead of just trying to get an appointment.

I want more AI traffic! But what content is worth creating?

Eric, I’d put the next content dollar into helping a shopper choose an actual vehicle, not another generic “best SUVs” article.

Pick 10 live VINs and look at them like a customer. Take two same-year Grand Cherokees with the same trim badge. Can you tell which one has the package you want without calling? Does the VDP match the window sticker or build information where available? Is the advertised price clear about conditional rebates? Is the unit actually on the ground or inbound?

That’s content worth building. Real equipment differences, useful VIN-to-VIN comparisons, and answers to the questions that determine whether somebody is ready to buy. Not the same generic description pasted across every VDP.

Then there’s the handoff. If the VDP, BDC, and desk aren’t giving the same answer on availability and advertised pricing, more traffic isn’t fixing that. And when a customer submits an inquiry, the VIN and whatever shopping information they agreed to share should follow into the CRM.

I’d be more interested in whether those shoppers turn into shown appointments and sold deals than whether an AI referral number went up.

Anybody actually auditing that from VDP to showroom?

App for Advanced search on Facebook Marketplace – Need Your Feedback

Pavel, looking at this from the used-car desk, finding something below market is one thing. Figuring out whether it’s actually worth buying is another.


A car can look like a great deal on Marketplace until you factor in recon, the title situation, transportation, and what you can realistically retail it for.


I’d be interested in a way to build an acquisition watchlist by year, model, trim, mileage, radius, and maximum buy number. Then show which listings are new, which have changed, and which might actually be worth making a call on.


I’d also separate what’s confirmed from the listing versus what’s being estimated. That matters when somebody is making a buying decision.


Are you looking to build this more for consumers hunting deals or dealers sourcing inventory? I’d approach those two pretty differently.
  • Like
Reactions: paul_white

The AI Dealer is back — a free weekly newsletter for dealers

Alex, I can see the dealer homepage becoming less of the starting point. I’m not ready to say the same about the VDP.

A shopper might do most of their research somewhere else, but once they’re down to a specific VIN, the questions haven’t changed much. Is it actually available? Does it have the equipment they want? Is the pricing clear? Are we showing incentives they may not even qualify for?

The other piece is the handoff. If a customer has already narrowed things down by budget, trim, and trade situation, why are we making them start from scratch when the lead hits the CRM?

A broader content strategy makes sense, but the SRP, VDP, and desk still need to tell the same story. Otherwise, we’re just moving the disconnect further up the shopping process.

Curious where you see the VDP fitting into that strategy.

If Your Ad Budget Got Cut in Half, What Goes First?

This post in another thread == I would cut listing sites, or at least take them down to a very minimal spend and budget.

  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Kershner

The AI Dealer is back — a free weekly newsletter for dealers

AI Dealer said:

63% of buyers will shop with AI. Only 29% of dealers are ready.​

​


I've been thinking about this a lot. Almost shared some thoughts on it this morning, but I don't have the strategy fully articulated yet. I'm leaning pretty hard on how much less important a dealership website will be in comparison to a broader content strategy. More to come...
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Kershner

Best lead sources today for internet leads

They are using the dollars you give them, and your inventory, against you and driving up YOUR costs.

*** Think about this the next time they come at you with a price increase.
:iagree: Drew brings the bombs, and he's almost always right (almost is just for those times I wasn't around and he was wrong).

VehicleLyfe Release Notes

Unexpected words of encouragement from a great client!

Kristy Blackburn said:
“I’m a huge advocate for VehicleLyfe! It’s truly a great product that creates opportunities for our dealership. In just three months, we received 217 accepted appraisal offers! The level of customer engagement has been impressive, and the opportunities it generates are incredible. VehicleLyfe has proven to be one of our most valuable tools, consistently generating customer engagement and opportunities for our dealership. I would absolutely recommend VehicleLyfe to other dealers!”
— Kristy Blackburn, LaRiche Chevrolet Cadillac

Now I need to get her on DealerRefresh :poke:

Best lead sources today for internet leads

What I see more and more for the 3rd parties is that they have less "brand recognition" than they did in the past. AutoTrader used to be the 800lb gorilla, then others came onto the scene.

What I am hearing from a few people in the orgs is that less than 50% of the traffic to the big 3 (Autotrader, Gurus, Cars) sites is now organic or direct, meaning they BUY the traffic to the sites, using our inventory against us (dealers). A quick look at your Auction insights on adwords for your VLA/PMAX/Shopping campaigns will probably show something like the screenshot below. IMO -- They are using the dollars you give them, and your inventory, against you and driving up YOUR costs.

*** Think about this the next time they come at you with a price increase.

Edit: This screenshot is for a USED VLA campaign


1794596215752.png

AutoUnite Is Officially Live!

I think this is a very unique tool and I've enjoyed the website experience. I'd be interested in the 120-day beta for our group.

I see there are 3 packages. Which package will the beta be reflecting?

I was unable to find where you would submit a lead to a dealer on the website. Only contact details. Is that an available feature?
Thanks, kgall! Really appreciate you checking out AutoUnite. Glad you enjoyed the experience, and I’d love to talk about bringing your group into our beta!

The 120-day beta is completely free and separate from Standard, Pro, and Elite. It gives your dealerships a chance to experience AutoUnite before deciding whether a paid package makes sense. No credit card or automatic paid enrollment.

As for submitting leads, great question!

Since we just launched, we’re still growing our connected dealer network. Once a dealership is onboarded and its lead routing is active, shoppers can submit inquiries directly on eligible vehicle listings. Until then, you’ll see dealer contact information.

As more dealerships join, more shoppers will have the opportunity to connect directly.

For dealers, I think the biggest benefit is knowing more about what a customer actually wants before the conversation begins.

AutoUnite helps shoppers research vehicles, compare options, and explore payments before contacting a dealership. When they’re ready, our goal is to send the inquiry, along with relevant shopping information they’ve agreed to share, directly into the dealership’s existing lead process.

That gives your sales team a better starting point instead of just another name and phone number.

I’d love to learn more about your group!

You can check out our dealer page and beta details here:

Shoot me an email at [email protected], and I’ll personally follow up.

Thanks again for the thoughtful questions. We’re just getting started!

Kenny Smith
Founder & CEO, AutoUnite
  • Like
Reactions: kgall

Filter

🔥 This Week 5 threads · 44 posts
Marketing & SEO
MCP from CDK & Reynolds and other DMS companies
Dealers and vendors debate how soon CDK, Reynolds, and other DMS providers will offer Model Conte...
Best lead sources today for internet leads
Dealers are debating which third-party lead sources deliver the best ROI, with shared Q3 close ra...
I want more AI traffic! But what content is worth creating?
Dealers are chasing AI traffic and GEO/AEO metrics without first asking whether that traffic can ...
Community
How to be a respectful vendor
A first-time poster and early-stage vendor asks the DealerRefresh community how to prospect deale...
Is improving new-vehicle affordability actually showing up in the showroom?
Dealers are questioning whether reported gains in new-vehicle affordability are actually moving m...
Get this delivered every week