• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

5 Reasons to Forget About Your SEO

I agree, nice article. I even agree with the 52% organic remark. It's interesting though... That with an SEO strategy that 52% of organic traffic represented tens of thousands of website visitors versus the 1 thousand visitors it represented when we began with our SEO strategy in the fall of 2006. The ROI becomes infinite when you have your employee(s) trained to do this vs paying a company to do it for you.

I just don't see the urgency of ppc. With products like Dealer.com's dominator and ReachLocal there isn't a whole lot of need to get right on PPC. Sure, have budget... Now what?

Send a check. Problem solved. If you're suggesting a ton of strategizing needs to be done, this just isn't the case. Algorithms are far more successful managing bid strategies than people are. So where's the urgency?

$2k/month for rural small store. $5k/month for larger metro store. Next... I mean, back to SEO...which has changed DRAMATICALLY! AGAIN!

5 Reasons to Forget About Your SEO

Terrence, great post and Title. Dealers need both SEO and SEM for a comprehensive digital marketing strategy. There is no doubt that SEM produces immediate traffic, however it does not guarantee that the investment and traffic will be profitable.

I would like to add that SEM is only effective if the clicks are taking consumers to proven landing pages that convert on the click. The automotive industry is just waking up to landing page conversion optimization, and Larry Bruce has been like John The Baptist preaching to the deaf.

I believe that dealers who want to increase their market advantage in 2011 will need to increase resources to inspect their analytics and work on conversion testing. These are two of the top 5 things dealers need to prioritize this year.

Just as a bad SEO strategy is a waste of money, pumping thousands of dollars of Adwords spending to send shoppers to the home page of the dealership website or to an inventory listing page can be a big waste of money. I see this basic setup all the time.

In 2011, I would like to see more dealers understand that conversion of traffic, SEO and SEM, must be the next step in the evolution of automotive advertising. SEM has great control and instant traffic but it takes skills that most companies are not offering dealers to do a real controlled A/B test on landing page designs.

PCG is starting a free 8-week SEM study on February 15th to start educating dealers on how to setup, test, measure, and refine their PPC spending. I totally agree that PPC should be used by all dealers, and they should test the broad high volume phrases like "used cars", "used ford", "used nissan", "cars for sale", "toyota dealers" with a conversion focus.

Are dealers interested in learning more about Adwords? 110 dealers signed up for this free 8-week training program to date, so I would say that your article is right on the mark.

DealerRefresh members can still sign-up until February 1st at http://www.automotivesemstudy.com for this free study.

5 Reasons to Forget About Your SEO

Terrence - nice article. You're absolutely right when you say "Yes, your Google Analytics shows that 52% of your traffic is “Organic”. Guess what. The majority of that Organic traffic is for your Trademark terms. And it always will be assuming you have been around for a while and have done a decent job at branding."

I'm sure every website provider can prove this to be true for dealers who take the time to brand themselves (most do). It is very easy to get caught-up in your analytics to see organic search results having very high conversion rates, but that's because most of those results are based on dealership name searches. Dealership name searches = consumers specifically looking for you. They wanted to contact the dealership before typing [DEALERSHIP NAME] into Google, so naturally they're going to convert.

Visiting a dealership website is a means to an end. Simply visiting the website shows a strong buying sign.

If you want to entice shoppers earlier in the buying cycle your easiest search engine strategy is Paid Search. If you couple that with good SEO and relevant landing pages your success will be much higher than it is today.

If there is one thing I'd like to see people understand from Terrence's article it is that SEO and PPC are not two different expenses; they are two things that work together and you should be engaged in both.

5 Reasons to Forget About Your SEO

There I said it. Forget about long-tail, short-tail, META tags, “page one domination”, link-building, URL strings, SEO training seminars and SEO wiz-bang nonsense. Forget it. At least for the moment.

Unless you have a website in development or are switching providers where an SEO strategy is vital during the implementation of your new website, your #1 priority should be to have a PPC (Pay Per Click) marketing plan and budget in place for 2011.

Obviously SEO is a massively important strategy - one that should be implemented carefully and with the right data and people in place to do so. But this industry has become borderline infatuated with SEO without giving PPC the attention it deserves. I have dealers consistently making suggestions about their Page Titles or META data (impressive), but then go on to ask me if that will help them show up in the “pink box” at the top of Google. No, those are “Ads”. You have to pay for those.

Below are 5 top-level reasons and stats to get your brain on the right track about Search Engine Marketing (SEM) – the umbrella of SEO and PPC.

GROWTH
Automotive PPC spending for 2010 increased by 35% over 2009 along with increases consumer demand. OEMs, Tier 2 Associations and Dealers alike are increasing their budgets for 2011, which means if you don’t have a plan for Paid Search then most likely your competition does. (Source: Efficient Frontier)
Google-Content-Trends-SEM.jpg

TIMING
SEO is a long-term strategy with long-term benefits. It could be weeks or even months before you start to see the fruits of labor. New domains can take up to 12 months to hit their stride, but most SEO programs don’t plateau until between months 6-9. With PPC, you could be on the first page of Google inside of 48 hours.
Time-Periods-SEM.jpg

SEM-Map.jpg

CONTROL
With SEO, you have minimal-to-no control over how you appear in the search engines. Optimizing your website requires a keyword strategy first – of which most dealers do not have. Once your site is optimized, Google will choose what it sees what it likes, and what to display. With PPC, you have direct control over where, when and how your ads appear. You control the ad copy, the day-parting, the sites you want to appear on, your geographical targets, and even the page you want your visitors to land on. Google is offering more and more tools to help you control your PPC campaign. Additionally, a solid PPC program will give you invaluable information such as top-trafficked terms which you can use to build a more effective and efficient SEO program

TRAFFIC
This one’s a biggie. Yes, your Google Analytics shows that 52% of your traffic is “Organic”. Guess what. The majority of that Organic traffic is for your Trademark terms. And it always will be assuming you have been around for a while and have done a decent job at branding. Take a look at the rest of the terms. There will be supplemental traffic from additional SEO rankings, but you won’t see the type of direct influence from SEO on individual keyword traffic as you will from PPC. Side note – a good SEO keyword strategy will include high-focus on 1-3 top-trafficked keyword phrases.
Analytic-Trends-SEM.jpg

Keyword-Trends-SEM.jpg

ROI
Here’s where it gets tricky. Although both PPC and SEO have been proven to produce the highest ROI when compared to traditional marketing, PPC should have a lower ROI in the short term, while ROI for SEO increases over the course of the program. For SEO, as organic rankings start to climb, traffic, leads and sales should go up thus increasing your ROI. However, with PPC your ROI can be measured instantly and more accurately. Within 5 days you should have your average Cost Per Click, your total spend, total traffic and total leads. From there, it’s a simple equation. More money = more leads. And it’s this direct affect that makes PPC an invaluable advertising medium.

Both SEO and PPC are changing dramatically, and obviously you as an automotive dealer (business owner) should have a solid handle on both. SEO has become more than just getting better /higher organic rankings with direct correlation to ORM (Online Reputation Management) and Social Marketing. PPC is also changing with new strategies and methodologies being adopted by the engines. Amongst many changes including comparative and more visual ads, we predict more emphasis by advertisers and the engines on CPA (Cost Per Action), which means you don’t pay unless someone takes action such as filling out a lead form or clicking to call.

Overall, it’s impressive to see the Automotive community come together, show interest and devote resources to improving their online marketing. My advice is to do your research, become knowledgeable and then put the right people in place to make it happen…preferably not you or anyone within your dealership. After all, you have cars to sell and customers to service.

Dealerskins and XIGroup Come Together

Always interesting when two competitors merge. Will one of them become the Alpha and cannabalize the other? With so much duplication of manpower and technology, something has to give. There are obviously talented people coming from both companies. It will be interesting to see how this one plays out.

Dealerskins and XIGroup Come Together

Dealerskins and XIGroup

Nashville,TN, January 24, 2011 – Dealerskins, Inc., the premier provider of websites for automotive dealers nationwide and a division of Dominion Dealer Solutions, today announced its sister company, XIGroup, will unite under the Dealerskins brand to provide the most comprehensive website solutions for auto dealers.

The merger of the two Dominion website businesses is part of an overall company strategy to provide a complete website, CRM and Inventory solution to reduce the time and frustration often experienced when using multiple technology products. Robert Berndt, president of Dominion Dealer Solutions, stated, “We recognize the need to simplify the technology options available to auto dealers. By integrating two premier website providers and leveraging best in breed products and services, we create a powerful solution for existing and future clients that is difficult to match in the automotive industry.”

Joe High, general manager of Dealerskins and XIGroup, will remain general manager of Dealerskins and will lead the unified team. High explained, “Our organizations have been providing custom website solutions to car dealers for over a decade. Through the joining of these award-winning companies, our clients will benefit from shared technology, in-depth industry knowledge, and increased resources. We emerge with a common vision, strong product strategy, and the ability to deliver optimized web solutions to our clients in 2011 and beyond. It’s a perfect way to begin the New Year.”

The company will continue to maintain existing products and services for both Dealerskins and XIGroup clients with the same level of support and dedication. Additional product and service offerings which result directly from this unification will be announced in early 2011.

Dealerskins will remain headquartered in Nashville, TN, with a regional office in Baltimore, MD.

About Dealerskins
Dealerskins, a division of Dominion Dealer Solutions and leader in automotive dealer web services has been building the most innovative dealer websites in the automotive industry since 2000. The company’s expertise comes from real-world dealership experience and a passion for listening and responding to dealers’ needs. With a staff of industry leaders that stays on top of the trends, Dealerskins is focused on designing beautiful websites and building comprehensive web tools for auto dealerships while optimizing the car shopper’s experience to deliver more quality leads to car dealers. For more information, visit www.Dealerskins.com.

About Dominion Dealer Solutions
Dominion Dealer Solutions helps car dealers attract, retain, and service customers for life. Dominion Dealer Solutions products include: lead generation through IFMG; customer relationship management tools through Autobase, AVV, and @utoRevenue; Web sites through Dealerskins and XIGroup; and specialized data aggregation, management, and reporting services through Dealer Specialties, Cross- Sell, The DataCube, and DataOne Software. These businesses serve more than 60 percent of auto dealers nationwide. Learn more at Automotive Software & Technology | Dominion Dealer Solutions. Dominion Dealer Solutions is a division of Dominion Enterprises, a leading marketing services company serving the automotive,
enthusiast and commercial vehicle, real estate, apartment rental, and employment industries. Please see Dominion Enterprises.

Do You Know Your Dealerships BBB Score?

Okay, Joe and the gang enough sales talk. The BBB likes to talk about their great reputation. Go to BBB roundup and read about their business. All these post just sound like another sales pitch to get people to pay their high fees. The BBB can call themselves a non-profit. But are you really a non profit if your owners and CEOs rank in thousands in salaries. huh? In regards to BBB.org. who cares. Anyone can be a .org for about 12.99, the cost it takes to register your domain in .org instead of .com or .net. As a SEO person, .org means nothing and if anyone here is keeping up with google you know that links don't count as much either. Only original content and useful information on your site matters. Yes you could google a company name and reviews the BBB will come up if a company is registered with them. This would be the same for any site that your site is listed under. You could also do a simple google search for directories and other places to list your business name and site like google and yahoo directories or in places like merchant circlle etc. Those are all for free btw. Notice I am not promoting any business. Please don't get ripped off by thinking if you pay for a link you will rank higher, that is so wrong it's embarressing someone woudl evern write it. If it was that easy why wouldn't every place just get a BBB link? Search the BBB on the 20/20 website or go to BBB roundup, it's worth your time and spread it to every other business owner you know.

Do You Know Your Dealerships BBB Score?

This is great stuff Joe! You're always one step ahead of others and this should be a must read for every dealer out there.

I see a day where a dealer with an amazing reputation will be able to use this to close customers. "Folks, let me show you our BBB rating, now take a look at our competitors rating, do you really want to drive over there and get jerked around?"

Do You Know Your Dealerships BBB Score?

Dealers, don't forget to get you link on your BBB page. This will be one of the strongest links you can get.

Any sites like the BBB that has been around, is well trusted, and provides users the data they seek (unbiased reviews) should be at the top of your SEO todo list.

Lastly, don't hide from bad reviews, embrace them! These can become "stories" in a sense, and 90% of the people who left the bad review could come around and become your strongest supporter.

Best investment for 2011, embrace review sites but bring it back to a longer conversation on your domain (website, blog, etc). Make it so individuals at your organization can reply individually and give them the training to do so.

Do You Know Your Dealerships BBB Score?

This topic DIRECTLY connects to dealers wanting to be in Social Media.

Mr Decision Maker, if you are chasing the Social Media Rainbow, but your BBB score SUCKS, you're not going to like it when Social Media's evil twin starts dishing out it's tough love.

Most dealers don't understand how online communities HATE ignorant self-serving bullies and will stop at nothing to crush the bully.

In the dealer's defense, consumers have become over-demanding monsters and this new wave of Social Media Transparency will empower them right into the stratosphere.

Do You Know Your Dealerships BBB Score?

I have been seeing Better Business Bureau results on a lot of business name searches for a while, but those have absolutely been showing up more prominently lately. Most of the time the BBB result has been on page 2 or 3, but I'm seeing it on page 1 more often.

Joe - nice catch. Like your last article about Dealer Reviews putting "droves of GMs and GSM’s in the fetal position, sucking their thumbs wondering how this all got away from them", the BBB could be another view into that very same future.....or a piece of that same future.

Yes sir - "you heard it on DealerRefresh first!" Thank you Joe!

Do You Know Your Dealerships BBB Score?

Do You Know Your BBB Score?

If you don’t… you and your shoppers will very soon.

betterbusinessbureau.png

You remember the BBB (Better Business Bureau) don’t you?  Yea, it’s the auto dealers nemesis from days of old and it has been totally off Google’s radar…forever.

Those days are about to end.  How do I know? Let’s take a walk, let me show you around and you tell me what you think after.

While looking into FaceBook best practices in the DealerRefresh forums, I came on to Terrance Gordon's post of John Eagle European's excellent FB work. I Google'd John Eagle European and GAK! to too my surprise, there it is! BBB at POSITION 7, just below the fold!

Next was to Google: John Eagle European reviews. GULP!  Position #1!

WOW!  I scurried around to other dealer SERPs (Search Engine Results Pages) that I was familiar with and found little evidence similar to John Eagle's SERPs.  What do we have here?  Is this a new day for the BBB, or, is this just noise?

I say it’s a new day for the Better Business Bureau.

Few automobile dealers know Google like we DealerRefresh’ers know Google.  Google is all about improving the user's search experience and we all know Google is ATTACKING local search results with all of the fire power Melissa Mayer can bring.  We know Google is all about authority and the BBB has mountains of off-line authority, measured in decades.

The BBB has what Google wants.  A Brand known everywhere, a new website makeover,  a decades old dispute resolution system, a simple grading system,  AND it's reporting transparency. All the above makes the BBB website the mother of all review sites.  For the Google's search quality team, it's got HOMERUN written all over it!  Oh, did I mention it’s a non-profit organization?  IMO, its indisputable that the BBB is one of those sites that Google wants in every search for a business name.

If this happens, it begins a new cycle of power for the Better Business Bureau.  Shoppers see and read the BBB reports. Then, as the shopper becomes a buyer, should the new buyer have issues, they will turn to the BBB for resolution.

Most dealerships with poor scores treat the Better Business Bureau as the crazy uncle in the closet, they all know he’s there, but no one talks about him. Well.. that crazy uncle just inherited a million dollars and he wants OUT. I've been watching this set-up for months. Here it comes!

Are you ready?

Remember, you heard it on DealerRefresh first!

How Can an Out-Of-Town Dealership Compete with Local Competition?

Matt Cutts says "..If you are a Mobile Business"... I am mobile. My sales reps routinely drive 1-3 hours to meet up with long distance customers. My concern is Google has added this feature for business that are mobile, and car dealers aren't classically labled as "mobile".

On Google's end, to reduce abuse, it would be easy to create a list of all businesses by SIC code, then place a grade on how likely a business is to offer mobile services, then create a algo to search their site for mobile use.

I'm on the fence. I've been entertaining removing my radius. Not only because I've noticed little difference but i'm concerned with SPAMing the maps.

Sleepless in Syracuse...

How Can an Out-Of-Town Dealership Compete with Local Competition?

Brain Pasch came thru with this sugestion here several months ago and I changed my local settings to 75 mi and saw little to no effect. This does not mean it dosent work, it just didn't work for me. I am up to my aprmits in trying to make Google happy with my Google Places listings and that ain't easy!!

You got a STD? (Social Trusting Disease)

Jeff, I agree with you regarding ratings and reviews. Most GM's have not a clue and some have had their in-house "internet" gurus write fake reviews that are so bad they make you laugh. Others see some of the big auto review sites as a form of legalized extortion which given their lack of transparency I would agree with. But with Google's recent inclusion of 3rd party reviews with their organic search results, dealers have to be proactive right now.

You got a STD? (Social Trusting Disease)

Jeff: As you know, it the early days(late 80s/early 90s), dealers were skeptical of needing an internet site. Reviews/Reputation management will slowly evolve as videos and.... So be it. Nothing like having a free competitive edge as a franchise, UC operator or group. I must say the group that I am in is relatively akin to most dealers' 'not' staying ahead or on the curve of consumer activity. Afterall, when they were selling vehicles, the internet did not facilitate the selling of cars... You do know that in college a BS degree for most Business degrees is a Science degree. Maybe at large someday in this profession as more of a Science. For now, change is constant, action is too often optionally neglected.

Filter

🔥 This Week 5 threads · 38 posts
Marketing & SEO
AI = Awesome Intelligence
Dealers and AI power users share frustrations and observations about frontier AI tools like Claud...
PPC Fraud and bad oversight - at 92% of dealerships
Steve Stauning argues that PPC fraud and waste are rampant at dealerships, largely driven by OEM ...
Website Trade-In / Purchase Tool
A dealer asks about building a custom in-house trade-in and car buying data collection tool after...
General
Slate - the vehicle we have been needing
Dealers and industry pros discuss the Slate EV, a $25,000 bare-bones electric pickup that emphasi...
Community
What causes more frustration in vendor relationships?
Dealers and vendors debate their biggest frustrations in vendor relationships, with overpromising...
Get this delivered every week