- Apr 7, 2009
- 5,285
- 2,638
- Awards
- 10
- First Name
- Joe
Sharing another point of measurement for website vendor decision making.

Link: GTmetrix Performance Report

Link: GTmetrix Performance Report

Two questions:Why o why does our 'compare vehicles' suck?
And..
- Do we know how many customers use it?
- If the answer to the first question is low, is it because it sucks?
We built out an extensive comparison tool (as a vendor) and it was honestly a pain in the ass with little payoff.
I know why cars.com does well (SEO dealers name). Anyone know why/how Edmunds is killing it?

Joe Pistell, former Cars.com head of marketplace, returns to automotive digital retail experimentation after his 2022 resignation, launching a sequel to his original DealerRefresh 'Makeover Diary.' The thread covers vehicle merchandising benchmarks (praising Carvana and CarMax for their tight ops-to-engineering feedback loops), a search for a public-domain YMMT vehicle data library for SRP/VDP title mapping, and Pistell's heavy AI usage — culminating in him building a custom token consumption dashboard. The key insight is that traditional dealer web vendors lag far behind vertically integrated players because they lack direct feedback loops between the sales floor and the platform.