Websites, SEO, SEM, Display, Social, Marketing

Kevin O'Dea, an Internet Director at a small dealership, seeks advice on posting inventory across multiple Craigslist cities while avoiding ghosting and account flagging, citing strong sales results from out-of-area Craigslist traffic. The discussion covers strategies like using separate IPs, proxy rentals, and geographic limitations, with experienced user flosho providing troubleshooting tips on content optimization, HTML usage, and the recommendation to avoid posting beyond 2 hours from the dealership. The key insight is that successful multi-city Craigslist posting requires methodical testing of ad content and format rather than relying on automated services or proxies.

Chris Leslie solicits feedback from automotive industry professionals on a brief survey regarding how long the average car buying process takes. The thread appears to be research gathering for a forthcoming article, with no substantive discussion or conclusions documented in the provided content. The post is a straightforward request for survey participation rather than a debate or exchange of insights.

The thread's original post takes a provocative, tongue-in-cheek stance questioning whether customer loyalty even matters for car dealers, given that dealerships rank below Congress in trustworthiness surveys, new companies are emerging to help consumers bypass dealerships entirely, and younger generations are seen as indifferent to brand loyalty. The post appears to be setting up a debate or challenge to the conventional wisdom that relationship-building and customer retention are worth the investment in the automotive retail space. It invites discussion on whether dealers should bother cultivating loyalty or adapt to a fundamentally shifting consumer mindset.

Dealers debate whether to remove sold vehicles from online inventory immediately or keep them listed until delivery, with disagreements centered on lead quality versus SEO and customer experience. Two main camps emerge: those who remove sold cars right away to avoid wasting sales team time on dead leads and frustrating customers, and those who keep them up (either fully or as modified "sold" pages) to maintain Google rankings, prevent broken links, and capture additional leads that can be redirected to similar vehicles. A website vendor participant shares an innovative approach of keeping sold units online with disabled purchase options but prominent links to current inventory, while one participant suggests a real estate industry parallel of marking vehicles "under contract" to create urgency rather than hiding them entirely.

Ryan Thompson seeks advice on creating unique model-specific landing pages for his dealership's top-selling vehicles to boost organic traffic, and the community provides guidance on structuring content, managing pages across model years, and technical implementation through his CDK platform. Key insights include: treating old model-year pages as used vehicle resources rather than deleting them, building content on a controlled subdomain rather than relying on dealer management system limitations, and maintaining consistent optimization across mobile and desktop versions. The consensus is to start with one model as a test case, inject dealership personality into the content, and establish a clear framework before scaling to additional makes/models.

Gayle Rogers introduces Google's new Price Extensions feature for AdWords, which displays product prices directly in mobile ads for top-positioned listings, and invites community testing and feedback. The discussion reveals two significant challenges with adoption: regulatory concerns about pricing disclaimers (particularly from OMVIC) and Google's approval issues, including trademark complications and disputes over whether the feature is appropriate for lead-generation businesses versus direct sales. The key insight is that while the feature is innovative for driving bids, dealers may face approval hurdles and compliance questions before they can implement it.

The thread examines why automotive digital marketing effectiveness is declining despite increased spend, attributing it to market saturation as more competitors enter the digital space. The original post references data showing that online media has dominated automotive ad budget growth since at least 2014, and frames the challenge for dealers and GMs as reaching buyers at each distinct stage of the purchase journey rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all approach. The key insight is that differentiation and stage-specific targeting are becoming essential as the digital playing field grows more crowded.

A dealer named Nick shares his frustration with Dealer Fire holding his website and SEO content hostage when he wanted to switch providers, sparking a broader discussion about website ownership, platform security, and content portability. The community explores solutions like WordPress-based sites, content backups, and subdomain hosting strategies, while debating the merits and security risks of different CMS platforms. The key insight is that dealers should prioritize owning their website infrastructure and content from the start, with WordPress emerging as a practical (if imperfect) solution due to its portability and ability to recover quickly from security breaches.

Chris Cachor offers a desktop-only WordPress theme designed specifically for dealer websites, sparking a debate about whether dealers should use ready-made themes versus proprietary vendor platforms or build in-house solutions. The discussion highlights a key tradeoff: vendor platforms like Dealer Inspire offer flexibility and support but lock dealers into their ecosystem and risk SEO content loss if switching vendors, whereas owning your own WordPress site provides independence and content ownership but requires hiring dedicated staff with automotive expertise. The consensus leans toward in-house solutions for larger dealer groups that can afford full-time teams, while smaller operations must weigh the convenience of vendors against long-term control and portability.

The thread promotes Dominion's soft credit pull technology as a tool for dealerships to identify conquest opportunities directly from the service drive by assessing customer equity positions in real time. The core pitch is that these pulls require no customer consent, SSN, or date of birth, are FCRA-compliant, and give dealers full ownership of the firm offer credit. The key insight is that service lane visitors — including non-buyers — can be quietly screened for upgrade or switch opportunities without friction.

DealerRefresh users discuss the sale of TRADER Corporation (AutoTrader.ca's parent company) for C$1.575 billion to private equity firm Thoma Bravo, speculating it was previously expected to be acquired by Cox Automotive. The conversation reveals significant frustration among Canadian dealers with AutoTrader.ca's outdated technology offerings, high pricing (over $1,000/week), and restrictive exclusivity contracts that limit competition and innovation in the Canadian automotive digital marketplace. Emerging competitors like CarGurus are gaining traction by undercutting prices by 90%, though dealers generally still view AutoTrader.ca as the dominant player despite its limitations.

• Locked

Paul Black asked for alternatives to Octoparse, a web scraping tool he was using to collect Yelp data, and received several recommendations including 80Legs, Apache Nutch, Python Scrapy, and BeautifulSoup. A moderator (Jeff Kershner) then questioned the legitimacy of the post, suggesting Paul may have been promoting Octoparse and warning that the thread would be removed for violating community guidelines.

Kia has implemented a policy denying co-op reimbursement for in-house PPC advertising, instead offering 100% reimbursement only through approved vendor partners—a "forced choice" approach that dealers argue is restrictive even if not technically mandatory. The discussion reveals frustration with this practice, concerns about vendor performance and inflated spending (one dealer reduced PPC costs to one-third while maintaining traffic), and recognition that the policy benefits Kia operationally while limiting dealer autonomy and potentially increasing costs.

A dealer shares their Cost Per Lead (CPL) metrics across multiple sources (ranging from $18 to $225) and asks for peer benchmarks, but the discussion quickly pivots to the limitation of CPL as a standalone metric. Forum members argue that CPL must be evaluated alongside other factors like lead quality, gross profit per sale, service retention, and traffic source attribution to make meaningful performance decisions. The key insight is that a high CPL doesn't necessarily indicate poor performance if that source generates superior conversion rates, profit margins, or customer lifetime value.

Jeff Kershner, founder of DealerRefresh, shares that he's returning to ground-level dealership operations after more than a decade away, driven by timing, opportunity, and a desire to stay sharp and in touch with day-to-day retail. The post kicks off what appears to be an ongoing diary series documenting his re-entry into the dealership world. It's a candid, personal reflection that will likely appeal to anyone curious about the gap between industry consulting and the realities of the showroom floor.

A used car photographer asks whether high-quality photos justify higher pricing, and the consensus among experienced dealers is that great photos generate more traffic and buyer interest but don't directly command price premiums—instead, they prevent the dealership itself from being filtered out by consumers who equate photo quality with store credibility. The discussion evolves to suggest that quality photography can support a modest 1-5% price increase when all other factors are equal, and that transparent merchandising (including photos of damage) may actually build trust and reduce negotiation friction rather than devalue vehicles.

The thread discusses whether dealerships should use tracking numbers with area code restrictions on their websites and local listings, with ryan.gerardi arguing this practice is counterproductive since modern consumers often use cell phones with non-local area codes and would likely abandon the call if blocked. The responses suggest this is an outdated practice, though Jeff Kershner notes it may sometimes reflect dealerships retaining old toll-free numbers with legacy restrictions rather than intentional call filtering strategy. The overall consensus is that area code restrictions on tracking numbers are a poor marketing decision that unnecessarily limits potential customer calls.

Greg Schafer reports observing a notable decline in phone calls to his dealership while internet leads have increased, prompting speculation about whether consumers are shifting away from phone contact toward digital channels like chat and text. Two other dealers chime in with minimal corroboration—one reports steady metrics across locations, while another acknowledges that spam calls may be obscuring legitimate call volume trends. The thread lacks consensus on whether this represents an industry-wide shift in consumer behavior or is isolated to specific dealerships and regions.

Katie Barth announces major 2016 Google AdWords changes including removal of right-rail ads, new local search ad features with brand logos on Google Maps, and device bidding capabilities, citing mobile search statistics from Google's Performance Summit. A discussion ensues about the accuracy and context of Google's mobile conversion statistics, with craigh clarifying that the "3 out of 4 visit" statistic specifically refers to people searching for nearby businesses on Google Maps rather than all mobile searchers. The thread concludes with practical advice that dealers should begin preparing ad copy for these new features despite the phased rollout through year-end.

Aaron Wirtz, a journalist, shares a comedic song he wrote and performed called 'The Car Salesman's Lament,' set to the tune of 'Memory' from the musical Cats, performed at Wichita's Orpheum Theatre as part of the Gridiron show. The post is a lighthearted, one-off share with no substantive discussion or industry debate to follow. It offers a fun cultural moment for auto industry professionals who might appreciate the humor.

Ryan Everson discusses Google's expansion of character limits in AdWords search ads from 95 to 140 characters, positioning it as a way to make paid ads more closely resemble organic results and provide dealers with opportunities for more engaging ad copy. He advises dealers and vendors to prepare now to effectively leverage the additional character space to stay competitive. Chris Leslie expresses skepticism, suggesting the change is merely cosmetic and unlikely to meaningfully impact click-through rates, attributing it to Google's need to appear innovative as Facebook gains market share.

A dealer discovered that CarGurus caps search results at 2,000 vehicles and filters out overpriced listings regardless of whether dealers are paying for premium placement, meaning paying dealers can be excluded in favor of better-priced inventory from non-paying dealers. The thread debates whether this ranking system is fair, with some participants defending CarGurus's customer-first approach while others argue that paying dealers deserve transparency about how their vehicles are included or excluded from search results. The key takeaway is that CarGurus prioritizes deal ratings over paid placement, but dealers want clarity on the filtering mechanics that affect their visibility.