Websites, SEO, SEM, Display, Social, Marketing

A dealer received a Cars.com lead for a specific used vehicle but discovered the customer was actually sourced from CarsDirect, which the dealer had never authorized. The thread reveals that Cars.com purchases leads from third-party sources like CarsDirect and CarGurus without dealers' explicit knowledge, then redistributes them under the Cars.com brand, creating confusion about lead origin and dealer agreements.

The thread explores Google AdWords' call-only campaign feature, which converts ad clicks directly into phone calls, capitalizing on the stat that 70% of mobile searchers call businesses directly from search results. Dealers and marketers discuss how this compares to the older call extension feature and debate its practical value for automotive dealerships looking to drive more inbound phone leads. The key insight is that mobile consumer behavior strongly favors direct phone contact, making call-only campaigns a potentially high-ROI tool for dealers.

Costco has expanded beyond its new car buying program to test a used car buying service where franchised dealers list vehicles with remaining factory warranty and agree to discount prices by at least $1,000 for Costco members. One dealer shares that success with the program requires going beyond the basic guidelines—by negotiating higher discounts, integrating the offer across their digital properties, and treating Costco leads strategically rather than passively following program rules. The key insight is that third-party automotive services like Costco work best when dealers creatively optimize the program structure rather than simply accepting default terms.

• Poll

Dealership showrooms are predominantly running Windows 7, with some upgrading to Windows 8, though legacy systems like Windows XP are slowly being phased out due to performance issues. A major barrier to OS upgrades is DMS software compatibility—particularly ADP's Web Suite, which doesn't support Windows 8 Pro—forcing dealerships to choose between staying on outdated operating systems or switching DMS providers entirely. The discussion highlights a broader tension in the industry where older software architecture limits technology adoption and security improvements across dealership operations.

Stefan introduces Google Trusted Business View, a Google Maps feature allowing certified photographers to create interior 360-degree photo tours of businesses like car dealerships, and invites active photographers in the automotive industry to introduce themselves and share their services. The thread generates interest from dealers exploring the marketing opportunity for showcasing showrooms and service departments, with participants requesting photographer referrals in their regions. A Google Trusted Photographer named Thomas Hayden (GigaView360) joins the thread as a resource, establishing it as a potential networking point for dealers seeking this specialized service.

Mike Haeg explores the psychology behind why people instinctively seek out their own faces in photos and how savvy marketers can leverage this behavior to drive engagement on automotive websites and ads. The core insight is that featuring real, relatable human faces — not stock photography — in dealership marketing creates an instinctive visual pull that can meaningfully improve click-through and conversion rates. The thread invites dealers to rethink how they use imagery to trigger subconscious engagement before a single word is read.

A Ford dealer questions whether their website is underperforming, noting that only 15% of leads came from their own site versus 54% from manufacturer sources (Ford Direct) in their best month. Experienced forum members reassure him that lead sources vary seasonally and by traffic volume, but emphasize that dealers shouldn't rely solely on organic traffic—instead, they should actively drive traffic through PPC, email campaigns, and ensure their website is promoted across all customer touchpoints. The key insight is that while the dealer's website lead percentage may be lower than ideal, the real opportunity lies in implementing proactive marketing strategies rather than worrying about benchmark ratios.

Dealers discuss industry benchmarks for website visitor-to-lead conversion rates, with consensus that the national average for dealership websites is slightly under 3-5%, though vendors often dishonestly claim rates above 10%. Key insights include that Canadian dealers typically perform lower (1-3%), inflated traffic from broad marketing campaigns can paradoxically lower conversion rates, and some participants argue that measuring "search-to-visitor" ratios among engaged visitors is more meaningful than overall conversion rates that include high home-page bounce rates.

A dealership marketer raises awareness about Canada's CASL anti-spam law, which applies to US businesses with Canadian contacts and carries severe penalties (including a $1.1M case already filed), noting that enforcement could intensify when private lawsuits are allowed in 2017. Replies from Canadian participants express skepticism about the law's practical enforceability across borders and suggest that while some dealers are over-correcting their practices, basic database cleanup and compliance is prudent protection against future liability.

Automotive dealers discuss common website frustrations, ranging from UX issues like poor navigation, inconsistent fonts, and oversized homepage ads to functional problems like outdated inventory, missing prices, and lack of search filters. Key complaints include overly complex dropdown menus that confuse shoppers, the inability to save vehicle comparisons, and missing autocomplete features—with several participants noting these issues are widespread across franchise dealer sites. A broader frustration emerges around OEM-mandated website templates that limit dealer autonomy and fail to serve local business interests.

Cars.com analyzed dealer reviews to identify common shopper pain points and emerging trends, with seven in ten car shoppers rating dealership reviews as 'very' or 'extremely' important in their research process. The thread republishes a Cars.com DealerAdvantage blog post to surface these insights for dealer professionals. The data underscores how critical reputation management and online reviews have become in influencing automotive purchase decisions.

A dealer asks what traffic and lead increases to expect when switching from a manufacturer website to an independent dealership site, and whether growth is possible without significant SEM spending. The discussion emphasizes the importance of establishing baseline metrics through Google Analytics and post-sale surveys before and after the transition, and pivots to highlight that high-quality inventory photos are a critical but often-overlooked factor in driving online sales.

The thread focuses on optimizing the thumbnail (first frame) of dealership video content to maximize viewer engagement, with the original poster offering five actionable tips for making a strong visual first impression. The core insight is that with video consumption surging on mobile devices, the static preview image is a critical and often overlooked conversion lever that dealers should treat with the same care as the video itself.

A new CRM/Internet Sales manager in California asks about industry benchmarks for closing rates on third-party leads, given his dealership processes around 250 leads monthly across five sales staff. The responding expert cites 7% as the traditional industry standard closing rate for third-party leads.

A dealer considering switching to DealerOn seeks template recommendations from other users with the platform. Multiple experienced users provide strategic advice, emphasizing that template selection should prioritize the Vehicle Details Page (VDP) and Search Results Page (SRP) as the most-viewed pages, followed by homepage inventory accessibility and specials pages. The key insight is that template choices should be driven by the needs of silent shoppers rather than aesthetics alone.

Mitch Gallant shares a newly launched marketing podcast search engine (marketingpodcasts.com) as a resource for DealerRefresh members interested in discovering new podcasts. The post receives brief appreciation from several community members, with mostly positive acknowledgment of the tool's value. The thread serves primarily as a resource announcement rather than a discussion, offering a practical reference for dealers and industry professionals looking to expand their podcast listening.

A new Mazda sales manager seeks a "build your car" tool to boost sales at an underperforming dealership (20/month vs. competitor's 50-65/month), believing low inventory is the primary issue. Responders provide examples of build-and-price tools from other dealers and offer strategic perspective, with one experienced manager cautioning that the real solution involves building dealership reputation and customer experience rather than relying solely on a website tool, while questioning whether the owner is even committed to growing Mazda volume.

The thread argues that dealers must organize custom website content into dedicated directories to properly track SEO and content marketing ROI — otherwise, budget holders will cut those investments. The core insight is that structured content organization also protects those assets during future website platform migrations, making it a dual-purpose best practice for long-term digital marketing accountability.

• Poll

A dealer asks which review platform (Google, Facebook, Yelp, Edmunds, Cars.com, DealerRater) deserves priority when customers will only leave one review. The consensus favors **Google for SEO value and DealerRater for achievability and legitimacy**, though participants debate the trade-offs between third-party platforms (which carry credibility but lack control) versus building proprietary review solutions. Key insight: dealers should focus on platforms where customers naturally congregate—Google and DealerRater—and actively promote them, as passive organic reviews are rare.

A user shares positive impressions from an AutoDealerLive event focused on women in automotive, prompting other forum members to request access to the content. A recording of the event was located and shared, with instructions to skip to the 13-minute mark where the women in automotive segment begins.

Automotive dealers discuss best practices for building in-house photo studios, debating key components like turntables, lighting systems, backdrops, and workflow efficiency. The consensus emphasizes that professional guidance is critical, interior car photography is more challenging than exterior shots, and speed/consistency matter more than complex equipment that slows down the process. A major disagreement emerges between those advocating controlled indoor studios and those arguing that outdoor photography with natural light and the dealership building as backdrop produces superior, more authentic results.

A dealer defends TrueCar as a valuable lead source while acknowledging that most dealers in his network vocally resent the service due to increased costs and thin margins. The original poster argues that since savvy customers will seek competitive offers anyway, TrueCar simply formalizes this process and drives qualified traffic—a perspective that contrasts sharply with the majority complaint that the platform is financially unsustainable (though his supporting data appears to be cut off mid-post).