• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

What happens when the customer says no to your equity offer?

We keep running into the same story. A dealer has been on an equity mining or service drive tool for about a year. The first few months looked great. Now results are dropping fast, and text opt-outs are climbing.

No wonder... the customer comes in for an oil change and gets an upgrade offer. The monthly equity email shows up. On the next visit, there’s another offer. Most people ignore the text, but the system keeps firing the same message later. They finally opt out.

We have found that 1 in 8 service customers buy in the next 12 months. The other 7 are going to say no, and a lot of them hear the pitch every time they come in. The tool counts the deals it finds. It doesn’t count the customers it wears out. When those customers text STOP, your service reminders usually stop going out to them too.

  • Are you tracking opt-outs to your equity texts? Have they climbed since you started?
  • Does messaging change on subsequent customer visits?
  • Is the tool only focused on trades/acquisitions? Does it present other options for the customer?

OpenAI New ChatGPT Plan

Cutting costs and boosting profits still equate to one another.

Could not agree more about the prepared AI written speeches though. I think people that don't use AI as much as some of us, somehow do not see it. No different than when you see an AI generated female on social media... Then you look at the comments and 90% of the people dumb guys) think it's a real human and they make some of the creepiest responses. Yeah, slutty AI Sarah is going to go on a date with you. ‍:rofl:

Your website might be invisible to ChatGPT and nobody at your store would ever know - AEO / GEO Megathread

Opps,DealerInspire client McGuire is still invisible to AI shoppers:

I asked GPT:
go to this website, can you see this car?
https://www.maguirecars.com/invento...untry-four-wheel-drive-suv-1gns6tkl8tr102668/

[the test failed, I followed with this message]

I followed up with GPT:
if I was car shopping and you were my agent, would this car make it into my consideration set? How many other car dealers have this problem?

This Tahoe could fall out of your consideration set because I cannot inspect it.

As your shopping agent, I need price, mileage, condition, equipment, and location to compare vehicles. If I can verify competing cars but cannot verify this Tahoe, those competitors move forward. Your direct link keeps the Tahoe on the list as “needs verification.” Without that link, I might never surface it.

How many other dealers have this problem? UNKNOWN. This session does not establish an industry rate—or prove that Maguire blocks AI agents.
We observed two different failures:
ObservationWhat it establishes
Web lookup could not access two Maguire listingsThat lookup could not read those pages.
Browser permission check denied the Tahoe requestThis browser did not reach the listing. It does not establish a dealer-side block.

For Maguire, the business question is concrete: Can an AI shopping agent discover a vehicle, read its details, and put it into a comparison? If any step fails, the dealer risks losing consideration before the shopper ever visits its website.

  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Kershner

Your website might be invisible to ChatGPT and nobody at your store would ever know - AEO / GEO Megathread

We worked through the issue with two dealers and escalated it through DI. To their credit, their support team pushed it up and ultimately got Claude access resolved across DI sites.

I just tested a Maguire VDP again. Both ChatGPT and Claude can open and understand the page with a very basic prompt:

“Open this page and tell me about the contents: ”

DR readers, Corey is good follow: Corey Lydstone - Car Genius AI | LinkedIn

OpenAI New ChatGPT Plan

I just feel bad for all the projects kicking off now... The early days are over and the subsidized builder space is sunsetting fast. Welcome to IPO for sure. AI is gonna start burning in-house cash and new startups really fast.

Expect Claude to do likewise in the very near future.

Sianara magical early window.


ya,@Alex Snyder was 1st to point out to me that when wall street stops funding the free ride, AI dev work costs are going to explode. I am boot strap and dammm the costs are rising fast but the work I get done is magical.
  • Like
Reactions: Alex Snyder

What are you actually tracking on your salespeople?

One of my favorites was the email response rate. Send a bunch of emails but get single-digit responses, and I know you need training.

What got me into this was a salesperson at our Honda store who had an AMAZING email open rate. Zero response rate. It made no sense. The subject line to every email was "I just want to FU" :lmao:
  • Hilarious
Reactions: carguyfiles

What do dealers wish transportation companies did better?

Hey everyone — Chris with ASAP Transport Solutions.

I wanted to introduce our company, but also get some feedback from the dealer side of the business.

ASAP Transport Solutions is an FMCSA-authorized transportation broker (MC 815288 / USDOT 2380139), BBB A+ Accredited, and we’ve been coordinating vehicle transportation nationwide since 2012.

A large part of what we do involves dealership transportation:

• Dealer trades
• Auction-to-lot transportation
• Wholesale inventory moves
• Inventory rebalancing between stores
• Dealer-to-customer deliveries
• Open and enclosed transportation
• Individual units and multi-vehicle moves

One thing I’m curious about is how dealerships here are currently handling transportation.

Are you primarily using Central Dispatch, a dedicated broker, your own transportation department, multiple brokers/carriers, or some combination of everything?

From our side, one of the biggest advantages we see dealerships getting from a good brokerage relationship is having one point of contact who can source capacity across a large carrier network rather than being dependent on one carrier’s trucks, equipment, or lanes.

We’re obviously happy to help if anyone needs transportation, but I’m also here to contribute to the community. I’ve been in transportation for years, so if anyone has questions about carrier pricing, difficult lanes, insurance, vetting carriers, auction transportation, or why a vehicle isn’t getting picked up at a particular rate, I’m happy to give you my perspective.

Would also love to hear what dealers wish transportation companies did better.

ASAP Transport Solutions
Ship With Confidence Every Time
www.asaptransportsolutions.com
I despise the cold calling, especially when I am still shopping the same sale they are calling about. I hang up on them every time as soon as I figure out why they are calling.

I have a good relationship with a driver who moves most of my stuff. If something is outside of his range, I will look at the carrier who is partnered with the site I am purchasing from. Most of my sites utilize carsarrive and I will usually use that for the quick and easy way to purchase it at checkout. If I don't think the price is fair I would get in touch with one broker I use from time-to-time.

OpenAI New ChatGPT Plan

Open AI announced a new plan tier for $500/month. In turn they cut the current $200 pro plan in half. Gotta get those profits up before the "delayed" IPO.

New tiers:

PRO
$500 plan includes Astra Ultrafast
$200 and $100 get no Ultrafast

PLUS
$20 gets you GPT-6.1 Sol and GPT-6 Luna

GO
$8 gets you GPT-6 Luna (standard speed)

Who sees the value in this with so many alternatives?

GM Lead Response Time Questions

Hi Gang -- having some interesting conversations about GM lead response tracking (stop-the-clock) with Shift (it's still Shift, right?).

Discussion threads:
* Autoresponders DO NOT stop-the-clock
* Personal emails DO stop-the-clock
* CRM-logged phone calls (VIN, ELeads) DO stop the clock.

Is it true that GM is now expecting 24-hour coverage for lead response? They want phone calls and/or emails at 03:00 AM?

Who's got the truth here?

Thanks!!

JQ

Your website might be invisible to ChatGPT and nobody at your store would ever know - AEO / GEO Megathread

Dealer Inspire had better get this fixed fast.

GPT assessment of DI:
The feed is accessible. The cause of the vehicle-page failure is still unknown.

The exact URLs are:

I need to correct my earlier explanation: I constructed the vehicle-page URL from a common URL pattern. I did not obtain it from the dealer’s actual listing link. Its failure therefore does not prove Maguire blocks AI.

What this session established:
1791037139989.png
Your first diagnostic step is to test the actual Tahoe listing URL. Then check server logs for crawler requests and response codes. Those checks distinguish a wrong URL, a security block, and a page-rendering problem.

This session shows a discovery advantage for CarGurus, but it does not establish the cause of Maguire’s low AI traffic.
Cloudflare is a plausible cause, but this session does not prove a Cloudflare block. My retrieval tool returned “not accessible.” It supplied no HTTP status, response headers, or Cloudflare challenge page.
Cloudflare can block or challenge automated requests through its bot protection and firewall rules. Being a Cloudflare customer does not establish that DealerInspire enabled those rules for Maguire.

Ask DealerInspire to check this:
Check Cloudflare Security Events for Maguire’s domain around October 3, 2026, 10:05–10:16 a.m. Eastern. Identify any blocked or challenged AI retrieval requests. Return the requested URL, action, matched rule, user agent, and Ray ID. Also check AI crawler controls and bot protection settings.

A matching Block or Managed Challenge event would establish Cloudflare’s role. Without that evidence, blaming Cloudflare would be premature—especially because my attempted vehicle URL was constructed and may have been wrong.


Dealer Inspire says its Cloudflare configuration allows trusted AI access. A blanket AI block would conflict with its published policy.

Two official pages address this directly:

Official pageWhat Dealer Inspire says
AI-ready dealer websites — August 2025Cloudflare bot management allows trusted crawlers. Its allowed-access list names OpenAI, Google, Microsoft, and Anthropic.
AI Inventory Boost — April 2026An AI-optimized inventory feed helps AI find and match vehicles. It repeats that trusted AI assistants can access sites through Cloudflare.
These are Dealer Inspire’s published claims, not verification of Maguire’s actual configuration.

For Maguire, the next step is to verify that the live configuration matches that policy. Our search found inventory-feed data, but my failed vehicle-page request used a constructed URL. That failure cannot establish a Cloudflare block.

Ask Dealer Inspire: “Does Maguire’s domain follow your published AI-access policy, and can you demonstrate successful AI retrieval of this Tahoe’s actual vehicle page?”
  • Like
Reactions: carguyfiles

People's Choice Awards for Best Vehicle Photos?

From a biz POV, this shooter is a pro. Their attention to detail is great, but, this shooter KNOWS who's looking at his pics and the shooter is making an effort to make the shopper/viewer happy.

1790996569540.png

1790996546682.png

1790996958894.png

1790996978196.png

2 thumbs up, way up
(and no AI and no booth)

DISC?
Hell Yea.


Your website might be invisible to ChatGPT and nobody at your store would ever know - AEO / GEO Megathread

To be fair to DI, their own page says they let verified crawlers from OpenAI, Google, Microsoft and Anthropic through Cloudflare. Grok and Perplexity aren't on that list, which matches your test.

GPT = No Dealer Inspire
"I could not read Maguire’s page directly, so the dealer still needs to confirm the advertised price."
  • 🙄
Reactions: carguyfiles

Can too many Vehicle Photos be a bad thing?

That's so interesting.

What if attention spans are shrinking so fast that people are missing out on their perfect car because they aren't willing to go through all the photos???

For example, they would've bought this one but since adaptive cruise was buried, they never saw it, so they hit the exit and went to another car or dealer site.
That is what we suspected was happening when we ran the study 11 years ago. Totally anecdotal reference, but raising 4 teenagers over that period of time tells me that attention spans didn't get longer. ;)

"Give the customer what they want" has become "Anticipate what the customer wants and give it to them BEFORE they ask for it."
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Robbins

Your website might be invisible to ChatGPT and nobody at your store would ever know - AEO / GEO Megathread

Great write-up, Michael. Thank you. Any thoughts about dealer inspire sites being behind the Cloudflare wall?

Dealer Inspire dealers should be very mad.

Example, a car shopper writes:

"I like this car, can you find me one like this at a better price? My zip is 13029.
https://www.maguirecars.com/invento...-base-fwd-4d-sport-utility-5xyzt3lb0jg526346/"

Grok:
That listing is a 2018 Hyundai Santa Fe Sport 2.4 Base, front-wheel drive, VIN 5XYZT3LB0JG526346. Maguire’s own page is blocked, but Autotrader has:

Grok Output:

Anyone else experiencing aggressive upsell tactics and retaliation from CarGurus?

Currently, the AIs that I've been using to go car shopping are using the third-party sites, classified sites, to go used car shopping. It was always my thought that AI would recognize that the inventory on these sites is not complete and that they would go past these aggregators and go directly to the retailer that's selling it. This is not the case so far in my circles.

Someone _should_ build an aggregator site just for AI that links to all dealers, or rather, presents the data from all dealers into an AI-centric, machine-centered UI. No advertisers, no fake sorting. Maybe some sort of simple subscription, just to validate the dealers' authenticity, to become a source of authority for the AI machines.

The Impact of Electric Vehicles (EVs) on the Car Industry

I think the biggest takeaway is that customers are becoming a lot less loyal to one powertrain and a lot more sensitive to what makes sense for their actual situation.

Gas jumps and suddenly EV searches go up. EV depreciation gets heavy and now a used EV can look like a tremendous value. At the same time, plenty of people still look at charging, range, insurance and resale and decide a hybrid or ICE vehicle makes more sense for them.

From the dealership side, I don’t think the answer is to bet everything on EVs or fight against them either. It is having the right mix of inventory and being able to explain the tradeoffs honestly.

What I’m seeing more and more is that the customer really wants someone to help answer: What actually fits my life?

How far do I drive? Can I charge at home? What will it cost me to own? What happens when I trade it? Is the incentive strong enough to make the numbers work?

That is probably where hybrids continue to have a strong lane too. They solve a lot of the fuel-cost concern without asking the customer to completely change how they use the vehicle.

To me, the winners are going to be the dealers who can sell all three without turning it into an EV versus gas argument. Give the customer the real numbers, the real tradeoffs, and let the right vehicle win.

Filter

🔥 This Week 5 threads · 44 posts
Marketing & SEO
MCP from CDK & Reynolds and other DMS companies
Dealers and vendors debate how soon CDK, Reynolds, and other DMS providers will offer Model Conte...
Best lead sources today for internet leads
Dealers are debating which third-party lead sources deliver the best ROI, with shared Q3 close ra...
I want more AI traffic! But what content is worth creating?
Dealers are chasing AI traffic and GEO/AEO metrics without first asking whether that traffic can ...
Community
How to be a respectful vendor
A first-time poster and early-stage vendor asks the DealerRefresh community how to prospect deale...
Is improving new-vehicle affordability actually showing up in the showroom?
Dealers are questioning whether reported gains in new-vehicle affordability are actually moving m...
Get this delivered every week