• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

DMS Systems, Data, Security, I.T.

All the fun stuff in the dealership. From DMS software to full-on statements, data policies and security.

Following CDK's ransomware attack, automotive professionals debate whether the company should pay the ransom, with discussion centering on backup strategies, the real costs of refusal (citing MGM's $110M loss vs. Caesars' $15M payment), and systemic security failures at major vendors. Key insights highlight that CDK's outdated infrastructure (14-year-old code using deprecated ASP technology), lack of independent security testing, and slow incident response made them vulnerable—problems that proactive penetration testing and modern security architecture could have prevented. The thread suggests paying a negotiated ransom may be economically preferable to the operational losses dealers face during extended outages, while also exposing how critical vendor security failures cascade across thousands of dependent businesses.

Replies
18
Views
7K

Dealer IT professionals discuss practical security challenges specific to automotive dealerships, including FTC/PCI compliance, employee negligence with customer data, and breach response procedures. Key recommendations include implementing ID scanning directly into CRMs, eliminating paper copies of sensitive documents, using hard-wired networks with separate guest WiFi, enabling multi-factor authentication, and establishing accountability through violation tracking programs. The consensus is that while dealerships have historically been fortunate to avoid major breaches, a combination of technical controls (EDR, RMM, encryption) and procedural discipline (securing physical documents, preventing email storage of sensitive data) is essential since no system is 100% secure.

Replies
15
Views
4K

A dealership discovered that 161 of its 707 phone numbers were flagged on spam/scam lists, significantly impacting outbound call connect rates, and forum members discussed the broader industry problem of phone number flagging and recommended services like Dealer Identity and Numeracle to manage compliance. The key insight is that many dealers are unaware their numbers are being blocked by customers' spam filters, and that manual remediation is complex and time-consuming, making third-party scrubbing services increasingly essential for maintaining call effectiveness.

Replies
8
Views
5K
EdmanBinn
E

A Priced Rite Auto Sales manager asks whether to upgrade from Microsoft Defender given new FTC compliance rules, prompting IT professionals from various dealerships to weigh in on antivirus options. The consensus emphasizes that while Microsoft Defender is adequate for baseline protection, the real security challenge isn't software choice but rather employee behavior and broader security infrastructure—including firewalls at the network level, data breach prevention, and account security—especially given dealerships' vulnerability to PII violations. Several professionals mention using enterprise solutions like Bitdefender, SentinelOne, and NinjaRMM, but stress that no antivirus software compensates for poor security practices or careless employees.

Replies
10
Views
5K

A dealer with exceptionally clean, manually-entered sales data dating back to 2019 seeks collaborators interested in using AI and data analysis to uncover actionable insights about inventory, leads, sales performance, and profitability correlations. Several technical professionals express genuine interest in helping, including a retired government programmer and a developer with a math background, though a commenter also suggests an existing tool (Carketa) that may already accomplish similar analysis. The thread demonstrates enthusiasm for data-driven decision making but lacks a clear resolution on whether the project will move forward or what specific insights will ultimately be discovered.

Replies
9
Views
3K

The thread explores synthetic identity fraud—a sophisticated scam where criminals craft fake identities over months or years that appear legitimate to dealerships and lenders—which costs the auto industry an estimated $8 billion annually and often leaves dealerships financially responsible per their lender agreements. Participants discuss detection methods (real-time document verification, selfie verification, and tools like PointPredictive) while debating whether existing solutions adequately protect dealers or if new fraud prevention tools are needed to address the growing vulnerability, particularly in online sales channels.

Replies
13
Views
6K

Omar, an independent used car dealer who has grown from 5 to 25 vehicles since 2020, is seeking advice about a recent six-month slump in deal closures despite maintaining steady lead flow across various credit tiers. He suspects tightening lending standards from major finance sources like Westlake and Flagship are the root cause and is looking for solutions or workarounds from the community.

Replies
0
Views
1K

A small independent used car dealership reported a three-week outage with Experian's AutoCheck Open Recall Reports service and sought alternative bulk recall reporting solutions. A forum member responded by recommending AutoAp as an automated alternative that scans vehicles daily and emails reports automatically. The thread highlights frustration with AutoCheck's service reliability and introduces an alternative vendor option for dealers needing consistent recall monitoring.

Replies
1
Views
3K

A dealer asks for guidance on using AI to generate an algorithm from Excel data, and receives a recommendation to try ChatGPT. The follow-up reveals that ChatGPT provided instructions on how to create the algorithm rather than generating it directly, leaving the user uncertain whether the issue was his prompt technique or unrealistic expectations about AI capabilities.

Replies
2
Views
2K

Bill Hoerr asks how to export GA4 custom definitions (ASC event parameters like flow, flow_outcome, comm_type) into BigQuery's native schema, which doesn't automatically capture them. Multiple respondents clarify that custom parameters don't appear in the default schema but are accessible by querying the `event_params` field directly using UNNEST functions, and some suggest bypassing custom definitions altogether by writing custom BigQuery queries to pull ASC data on-demand.

Replies
11
Views
5K

A dealer is seeking help configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) using Google Workspace credentials for a third-party vendor that supports OpenID Connect, specifically involving GCP integration. The post indicates they've followed setup instructions but are experiencing implementation issues. The thread addresses technical troubleshooting for enterprise authentication integration with Reynolds DMS.

Replies
0
Views
1K

A developer with a tech background seeks guidance on setting up a DMS (Dealer Management System) and related software for a small online consignment dealership. Community experts recommend HomeNet IOL as a cost-effective rooftop solution that handles inventory management, VIN decoding, and syndication to third-party sites, with the option to integrate via CSV feeds or APIs into a custom website backend. The consensus is that using an established DMS like HomeNet eliminates the need to build inventory management from scratch while providing essential dealer tools.

Replies
6
Views
7K

Mark A Hoffman shares a tool and sample BigQuery queries designed to help automotive dealers extract GA4 data aligned with the ASC (Automotive Standards Committee) standard, making it easier for professionals new to BigQuery to analyze their data. The tool allows users to input their BigQuery credentials and date ranges to generate ready-to-use queries without exposing their data to security risks. This resource aims to democratize access to advanced analytics capabilities for dealership professionals interested in leveraging BigQuery's analytical power.

Replies
0
Views
2K

Ryan Leslie announces his new role at Foureyes, a company launching a Unified Data Platform that integrates website, phone, CRM, and inventory data for dealers, and discloses this upfront to the community while emphasizing the product is market-ready rather than vaporware. The replies are largely welcoming, with fellow long-time DealerRefresh members acknowledging Ryan's credibility and history in the community, which gives him standing to discuss his new venture. The conversation quickly shifts to lighthearted banter about forum seniority and creating badges for original members, with no substantive discussion of the actual product or its features.

Replies
3
Views
2K

The thread discusses a significant class-action lawsuit against CDK regarding dealer data control and access rights, raising questions about whether dealers truly own their data when vendors restrict its use. While the original post references a lengthy court document with important implications for the industry, the conversation devolves into humorous tangents about legacy DMS systems (particularly Reynolds) still using outdated technology, with brief mentions of how OEM partnerships with newer platforms like Tekion and Salesforce may disrupt the traditionally concentrated DMS market. The thread doesn't develop a concrete conclusion about the lawsuit itself, instead becoming a lighthearted discussion about industry-wide resistance to modernization.

Replies
8
Views
4K

Automotive industry professionals discuss FTC Safeguards Rule compliance, with the consensus that the industry is poorly prepared (rated 3/10) and specifics remain unclear until court cases establish precedent—the key takeaway being to document all compliance efforts defensively. A secondary debate emerges about whether cookie consent banners are actually required under these regulations, with skepticism that such requirements (promoted by vendors like Complyauto) are being oversold similar to unnecessary compliance tools like ADA AudioEye, though some acknowledge cookies do meaningfully impact conversion rates and ad effectiveness.

Replies
1
Views
2K

A dealer shares a positive 30-day experience with Arkona DMS, praising customer service and noting the system lacks some advanced features but is functional. However, another dealer counters with significant frustrations about poor support responsiveness and CRM integration issues, suggesting success with Arkona may depend heavily on having a responsive account representative and internal IT resources to work around system limitations using APIs and custom queries.

Replies
8
Views
14K

Dennis Mendoza, starting an independent dealership targeting subprime buyers, seeks DMS recommendations and receives feedback that DealerCenter has integration and data export limitations. Multiple users recommend alternatives like Frazer, Wayne Reaves, and Desk Manager as more cost-effective options for small dealers, though Mendoza notes the platforms appear functionally similar for basic needs like inventory management, sales process, and marketplace posting.

Replies
12
Views
16K

A dealer sought recommendations for document scanning and archiving solutions for service records (ROs), parts documentation, and dealer jackets. The community discussed several options, with **Dealer Docx** emerging as the primary recommendation—praised for collecting, scanning, and destroying original documents while making files searchable online—though **One View** was also mentioned as an alternative solution. The thread was ultimately derailed by spam and self-promotion attempts, with moderators and members calling out suspicious vendors quoting themselves multiple posts apart.

Replies
10
Views
8K

Jeffrey Schwartz of Empire Data Management introduces his name consolidation and data cleanup services for CDK DMS users, emphasizing the importance of annual name file maintenance to improve efficiency and sales. After being asked about DealerTrack compatibility, he indicates willingness to expand his services beyond CDK to other DMS platforms at competitive pricing. The thread is primarily a vendor introduction rather than a substantive discussion about name consolidation practices or outcomes.

Replies
3
Views
3K

A dealer named Alex Snyder shares news of an Arizona court ruling against CDK and Reynolds & Reynolds that prohibits vendors from charging for access to dealer data, requires written permission before vendors can act on that data, and allows dealers to terminate vendor contracts with 90 days' notice. While community members express enthusiasm about the decision, Snyder urges caution, noting the ruling is limited to Arizona and raising questions about whether it will apply beyond DMS systems and whether other states will follow suit.

Replies
5
Views
6K

A dealer seeking to prioritize DMS integrations asks the community for market share data (rooftop counts) across eight major DMS providers representing the ~16,658 US franchise dealers. One respondent provides a specific data point that PBS holds 4-5% US market share and is growing, but the thread appears incomplete with limited additional responses providing comprehensive competitive rankings.

Replies
1
Views
4K