• This thread is just the tip of the iceberg.The people ahead of the curve aren't Googling for answers — they're already in here, having the conversations you haven't found yet. DealerRefresh is free.Get the full picture →

AMA FourEyes | Death by 1,000 papercuts: what’s yours?

I think there's more people struggling with wrapping their heads around Ai than we realize. I know I still struggle with it at times.

AI is like a really smart green pea. AI needs oversight and giadance. It's only as good as the boss that is working it.
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Kershner

Savvy Dealer vs Dealer On

I'm looking for a new provider because we've lost alot of our ranking. The VDPs can't be searched by google, and alot of the information on pages can't be seen either. We're in a small town as I said. we used to have the top 2 organic search for auto repair and we're number 6 now. I can't get a access to the back end to make any changes. The customers are having issues not being able to find what their looking at and calls to action.
I like Savvy Dealer but I can't find any information on them.

Business Management Software?

Agree with where this ended up. Power BI, Data Studio, or Tableau will build you a nice dashboard, but getting clean data into it is the hard part.

Honestly, unless you’re CarMax or a big group with your own data team, I think this is something you buy, not build. Database engineering gets messy fast if you don’t have someone who’s done it before.

We’ve been doing this with GA4, Google Ads, FB Ads, and inventory, with versioning and testing on the data. Just those have taken several months to work as desired. What the original post is asking for (marketing, CRM, DMS, purchasing, service) is a lot more than that.

Adding a new source gets a little easier each time since the pipeline is already built. Making it fit with everything else doesn’t. We run into scope and grain collisions all the time. GA4 tracks sessions, Ads tracks clicks and campaigns, inventory is by VIN, and the DMS is by deal. Getting all of that to agree on one customer or one car without over counting (fan out) stuff is a constant issue to be aware of. Like others said, no BI tool fixes that for you.

If you’re going to start on something like this, I’d recommend picking two or three sources that tie to decisions you make every week, getting those right, and adding from there. Trying to hook up everything at once is how these projects stall.
  • Like
Reactions: maxlw

Best lead sources today for internet leads

We're considering the "no 3rd party" experiment here. I'm not 100% sold that 3rd party is dead.

hey Bill, Dump one year of all your lead data into a CSV. Upload it to a good LLM, then, start asking it questions.

Example: I am the GSM, Act as my lead performance data analyst, I am considering turning one or more of these services off, build me an executive report. Be prepared for follow ups. Take your time and double check your work, do this correctly, I will be giving your work to a LLM auditor.

AMA FourEyes | Death by 1,000 papercuts: what’s yours?

I'll pick an idea or two and build a live app in 15 minutes to demo it on Friday.

Looking forward to that!

I like your timing, since dealers (and vendors) are just finishing their October closeout. Having an MCP to my Foureyes-connected data could be quite the month-end reporting speed-upper!
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Kershner

Your website might be invisible to ChatGPT and nobody at your store would ever know - AEO / GEO Megathread

I heard back from DI today. I'm not totally sure what it means as it is a bit above my skill level.
Has anyone else been able to fix their issue yet?

"Dealer Inspire utilizes best-in-class web security including a web application firewall (WAF), distributed denial of service (DDoS) protection, and bot abuse prevention technology from Cloudflare to protect our customers’ websites. While this technology blocks undesirable bot traffic, Cloudflare also maintains a list of recognized and verified bots that includes benevolent tools like search engine and AI crawlers. You may view the list of verified bots here, but of note, AI engines such as ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and a dozen more are already verified.

While Cloudflare does now offer the ability for websites to block AI crawlers, Dealer Inspire does not have this function enabled as indexing dealer inventory in AI search engines is valuable in this industry. Therefore, our customers do not need to take any action to continue allowing these verified AI crawlers access to their inventory listings.

Both malicious bot traffic and AI crawlers continue to evolve rapidly and having the protection of a tool such as CloudFlare to sort out the good from the bad should bring dealers peace of mind.

The use of Grok may be the core reason why this is being blocked but please let me know if you have further questions or concerns."
So the central issue is that before AI-agents came along crawler and bot traffic skewed analytics and reporting data because most website vendors weren't savvy enough to distinguish that traffic separately. There's also an added cost to serving that traffic. So aside from the major search engines and ad networks - that traffic was blocked (usually via Cloudflare or Amazon Cloudfront). There's a lot of malicious traffic searching for exploits and things too. So I get it.

But the right way to handle this going forward is two things: allow that bot traffic, but exclude it. Identify that (upstream in the network) as "likely" bot traffic before it even hits your website. Then you can still serve the content (it's cached anyways) but it doesn't mess up reporting data. Then the next step is to support an emerging technology called WebMCP. That basically tells the AI agent here's the AI agent way to consume my website. So essentially the agent can browse your site, add a trade-in, schedule an appointment, etc. and then the agent can report back or even forward you the email or add it to your calendar, etc. Wild times!

Best lead sources today for internet leads

We're considering the "no 3rd party" experiment here. I'm not 100% sold that 3rd party is dead. Probably helps we convert higher than all of these numbers. My recommendation was to try the barbell approach first before just dropping everything. Just lean heavy into one of them (most likely AutoTrader).

A thought:

About 20 years ago, Honda hired a survey company to call customers who owned Hondas, and they discovered that lessees were thinking about their next vehicle after 18 payments. Most of those people were in 36-month terms, so they couldn't move right then, but they were thinking about it.

We've been looking at engagement activity with the VehicleLyfe app and are seeing similar behaviors, but it isn't just lessees. Even people who paid cash start messing with cars they can buy at ~22 months after buying. This isn't every buyer, but it's significant enough for us to notice.

When people dream, they do it on 3rd-party sites and OEM sites. They don't dream on dealership websites, so you're missing the high-funnel traffic. By being where these folks are dreaming, you're building brand awareness and making impressions. "I wonder if Kirksville still has something like that 4Runner I saw in June?"

It may not directly translate into an attributable lead, but these channels still have value. Whether that value matches what they charge is another story.
  • :light:
Reactions: BillVaughnKMC

Best lead sources today for internet leads

What are some of your reactions to the data?

Hi ya Bill,

assume that 'par' = for every $grand you invest in a platform:
MarketplaceClose RatePerformance vs. Par (Over / Under)
Autotrader9.4%+46.9% (Over Par)
CarGurus6.8%+6.3% (Over Par)
Cars.com6.6%+3.1% (Over Par)
Benchmark (Par)6.4%0.0% (Par)
CarFax4.7%-26.6% (Under Par)
Edmunds4.0%-37.5% (Under Par)
TrueCar3.8%-40.6% (Under Par)

Quick dealer survey on social media (3 min, results shared with everyone)

Hey all,

I’m putting together a short report on how dealerships actually handle social media going into 2027: what posts get leads, how much time it takes, who’s making the content, and whether anyone’s using AI yet.

It’s a 3-minute anonymous survey. Everyone who fills it in gets the full results free in January, so you can see how your store compares.


If you’ve got a hot take on what works (or what’s a total waste of time), drop it below too. I’d love to hear it.

Thanks!
Shawn
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Kershner

Best lead sources today for internet leads

Third-party listing sites data. Autotrader... wow!

A person who wishes to stay anonymous thought these numbers would be helpful in this thread. This data comes from about 6,500 stores, aggregated by the CRM they all use. Sample size = 4.4 million leads.

77bd6e34-b678-4e9d-9e73-ffffde47e1ea.png


c9b24292-6841-438b-b420-991789174718.png

VehicleLyfe Release Notes

What's New: Selling to Your Service Customers

Your service drive is your best source of trades. Trade Paths price upgrade ideas with the customer's real equity; you can reach customers while their vehicle is still in the shop, and you can load your own customer lists into a campaign.

Reach customers while their car is in the shop When a customer's vehicle is on an open repair order, VehicleLyfe now sends them a timely message about their trade value and next vehicle options. The message includes the service advisor and whether they left in a loaner or shuttle, so the conversation picks up where the service drive left off. Dealers on DealerTrack, PBS, Automate, Autosoft, Tekion, Fortellis (CDK), Reynolds, and MIX (Authenticom) are all connected to the live feed, with years of history backfilled so day one isn't day one.

vehiclelyfe-release-152-20261102163905.png



Trade Paths bring suggested vehicles and dream vehicles to a customer when they're looking at their vehicle value. The three upgrade ideas built from a customer's equity now flow through the customer page, the activity history and the lead handoff. When a shopper taps an idea in the consumer app, it opens that car in illumiQUOTE with the trade and equity already applied, so the salesperson picks up exactly what the customer saw. Lease paths (when enabled) now show the equity that a lease structure cannot absorb, and lease deals cap the applied trade equity at 15% of the vehicle price so the quote stays financeable. The result: fewer broken handoffs between what the customer sees online and what the store can actually sell.

vehiclelyfe-release-143-20261102163905.png


Full notes and screenshots: What's New: Selling to Your Service Customers
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Kershner

Are used EVs moving—or only certain models?

I recently purchased a Pre Owned Tesla Model Y Dual Motor Long Range for my wife. What I noticed personally supports the post above. The equipment makes a big difference. HW4 Equipped vehicles are much more desirable than HW3 vehicles due to the Full Self Drive supporting future Autonomous Full Self Drive.

My wife's car went up in the Book about $1,600 yesterday. 2023 with 72K miles for reference.

I have some friends that sell a lot of Teslas, and again see above...the "right" ones do great, the wrong ones stick.
  • Like
Reactions: JLeo99

Aspiring startup founder — how are independent dealers actually using AI today?

Actually, I'm getting the most value from the $100-a-month Claude subscription. Mark Cuban recently said that software is dead; the biggest demand right now is helping businesses, especially small ones, figure out how to actually use AI.

Changes to DealerRefresh

DealerRefresh is faster :rocks:

We just did a number of upgrades. The slowness came from a PHP vulnerability we were susceptible to. After making a ton of changes to move to a newer version of PHP, we hit max disk limits on what is now our old AWS instance. The changes needed to sit for about a week before we knew everything was good to go. That week is done, and I upgraded the disks this morning.

Hopefully, it wasn't too annoying over the last week. Apologies if it was. Until the next crisis... enjoy some faster DealerRefresh.

VehicleLyfe Release Notes

Thank you Bill!

What's New: Cleaner, More Accurate Reports

Your reports got cleaner and more accurate: a 20 Group Report built for your meetings, a new Engagement Report, and a tidier Loyalty Report.

vehiclelyfe-release-145-20261029142323.png

Engagement Report The Engagement Report shows how your store is turning customer activity into sold deals and service visits. A summary band at the top gives you the headline numbers at a glance, and four lanes underneath walk through engaged customers, sold deals, service drive touches, and vehicle acquisition. Line and donut charts make the trends easy to read, and a heat map shows when your customers are most active. The report prints and exports cleanly, and the Vehicle Acquisition section explains where your trade-in opportunities are coming from so you can see which programs are actually feeding the used car lot.

vehiclelyfe-release-146-20261029142323.png

Loyalty Report cleaner and more accurate The Loyalty Report now shows three balanced profit-center cards on the Sales Team row, so the view reads cleanly without a crowded engagement tile. The live loyalty customer count also pulls from the same customer base the rest of VehicleLyfe uses, so the number matches what you see elsewhere. The report feels tighter and the headline count you share with your team is one you can trust.

vehiclelyfe-release-42-20261029142323.png

20 Group Report A new one-page report built for 20 Group meetings. It opens with the revenue VehicleLyfe helped bring back, split between service and sales, then shows how many lost and limbo customers were brought back and the funnel behind those numbers. Pick a preset range like Last Month or Last Quarter, or set your own dates, then print or save a clean letter-sized PDF to take into the room.


Full notes and screenshots: What's New: Cleaner, More Accurate Reports

Filter

🔥 This Week 5 threads · 44 posts
Marketing & SEO
MCP from CDK & Reynolds and other DMS companies
Dealers and vendors debate how soon CDK, Reynolds, and other DMS providers will offer Model Conte...
Best lead sources today for internet leads
Dealers are debating which third-party lead sources deliver the best ROI, with shared Q3 close ra...
I want more AI traffic! But what content is worth creating?
Dealers are chasing AI traffic and GEO/AEO metrics without first asking whether that traffic can ...
Community
How to be a respectful vendor
A first-time poster and early-stage vendor asks the DealerRefresh community how to prospect deale...
Is improving new-vehicle affordability actually showing up in the showroom?
Dealers are questioning whether reported gains in new-vehicle affordability are actually moving m...
Get this delivered every week