Websites, SEO, SEM, Display, Social, Marketing

Joe Chura argues that comparing website conversion rates between dealerships is essentially meaningless because most dealers aren't measuring the same conversion events, making apples-to-apples comparisons impossible. The thread explores how inconsistent definitions of what counts as a conversion — from form submissions to other tracked actions — can lead dealers to false confidence or unwarranted concern. The key insight is that before benchmarking conversion rates against peers or even your own historical data, you must ensure the underlying measurement methodology is identical.

Automotive dealers discuss how customer reviews on third-party platforms like DealerRater drive organic search traffic and impact dealership performance, with contributors sharing strategies for incentivizing staff to generate reviews and integrating them across digital channels. Key insights include that reviews boost local SEO rankings, increase click-through rates, build credibility, and can positively influence both dealership traffic and individual sales staff visibility before customers visit in person. The thread emphasizes that dealerships should prioritize review acquisition as part of their overall digital marketing strategy, not just as a peripheral concern.

A dealer asks about his experience with Haystack's SEM/PPC services, reporting drops in both paid and organic traffic after switching from a smaller local provider, plus discrepancies between Haystack's reported analytics and his own data. Multiple dealers confirm similar negative experiences with Haystack and recommend alternatives like Move Your Metal, while one user explains that Haystack's reverse proxy tracking methodology accounts for the reporting differences but shouldn't actually be losing traffic. The consensus is that inaccurate or non-transparent reporting is a dealbreaker—dealers should switch providers and prioritize vendors who can clearly demonstrate ROI and align their metrics with the dealer's own analytics.

A marketing professional outlines how dealerships should use Google Analytics as their 'virtual showroom up log' to detect suspicious website traffic, particularly from email conquest campaigns. The post walks through creating GA segments to identify abnormal click patterns on pages that real consumers wouldn't typically visit at high rates. The core insight is that dealers need to build routine monthly traffic inspection habits to catch fraudulent or low-quality clicks that inflate campaign metrics.

• Poll

The thread debates whether car dealers should handle marketing in-house or outsource to agencies, with participants agreeing the answer depends on dealership size and existing expertise. Key insight: larger dealer groups benefit from building in-house teams for cost savings and competitive advantage, while smaller dealers should partner with vendors but hire a tech-savvy staff member to oversee and measure results. The thread emphasizes that dealers need either the expertise to manage outsourced work effectively or the talent to execute in-house—hiring without clear strategy or measurement is ineffective either way.

Dealers discuss frustrations with Yelp's review filtering algorithm, which they claim suppresses positive reviews while displaying negative ones. The thread humorously proposes posting positive review content in a low-star review as a workaround, with one dealer confirming they actually attempted this tactic after experiencing Yelp filtering 39 five-star reviews while keeping a single one-star review visible. The underlying consensus is that Yelp's moderation practices are unfair and manipulative toward businesses.

Daniel Mondello opens with a Chinese proverb reframed for dealerships, arguing that dealers who fully outsource their marketing will always be limited by agency constraints—no vendor can be 100% effective 100% of the time. The thread advocates for dealers building in-house marketing competency rather than relying entirely on outside agencies. The core insight is that long-term sales performance depends on dealers understanding and owning their marketing strategy, not just delegating it.

A dealer asks how to get inventory listed on Yahoo Autos, discovering that Yahoo sources inventory from third-party aggregators like Detroit Trading and Vast rather than directly from dealers. After research and experimentation, the dealer learns that configuring an export through inventory management services like Vast can get listings on Yahoo without paying lead aggregators a markup fee, allowing leads to come directly to the dealership instead.

Dealers debate whether mobile apps are a worthwhile investment, with most consensus strongly favoring mobile-friendly websites instead due to poor adoption rates, high development costs, and unclear ROI for sales inventory purposes. The discussion identifies service departments as the only viable use case for dealer apps—where recurring appointments and integrated booking systems could drive genuine value—while dismissing sales and geo-fence marketing tactics as ineffective vendor pitches. A later update notes that emerging technologies like deep linking and CarPlay/Android Auto integration may eventually make dealer apps more relevant to SEO strategy and customer engagement.

An internet manager at a multi-store Harley-Davidson dealership seeks compensation advice after growing the internet department to 20% of sales and now managing a small team. The thread discusses various pay structure options, with an experienced eCommerce director recommending a base salary plus per-unit bonuses tied to overall dealer group sales (rather than just internet-derived sales) alongside quarterly CSI metrics. The key insight is that tying compensation to total dealership performance rather than just internet department metrics can reduce conflict and align incentives across departments.

Dealership professionals discuss who offers the best personal branding training for car salespeople, with overwhelming consensus pointing to Renee Stuart as the top resource in this niche. Key insight: effective personal branding requires deep discovery work and strategy—not shortcuts through logos, websites, or social media tactics—and those unwilling to invest should prioritize collecting customer reviews instead. The thread emphasizes that personal branding in automotive sales is about telling an authentic story and understanding what you actually want, which serves as the foundation for a profitable online presence.

A salesperson asks for recommendations on developing a dedicated website, and forum members overwhelmingly advise against standalone salesperson sites in favor of personal branding through social media and shared dealership infrastructure. Key concerns include poor long-term maintenance, inventory feed complications, and the consensus that individual landing pages within the dealership's main site—paired with a shared blog across all salespeople—creates better content consistency while still providing personal branding.

Automotive professionals critique Columbiana Chrysler Jeep Dodge's website design, with particular focus on its vehicle detail pages (VDPs) that bury product images below intrusive pop-ups, chat widgets, and excessive financing call-to-action links. The discussion emphasizes that effective website feedback requires first defining clear business goals and KPIs rather than making changes based on personal opinions, and that dealership websites should prioritize showcasing vehicles above the fold with minimal distractions. Key metrics shared include Columbiana's 8:18 average time on site, 2.8% conversion rate, and 24.93% bounce rate.

Dealers debate the viability and authenticity of no-haggle pricing programs (like Edmunds' Price Promise) being tested in major markets, with skeptics arguing dealers still negotiate on trades and add-ons while supporters contend that one-price models can maintain profitability and improve customer service. The discussion reveals tension between two dealership philosophies: those prioritizing gross profit per unit versus those focused on volume and repeat business, with participants disagreeing on whether salespeople can earn six-figure incomes under a transparent pricing model. The core insight is that no-haggle pricing's success depends less on the concept itself and more on a dealership's fundamental business model, market positioning, and willingness to retrain staff around customer service rather than negotiation tactics.

Automotive professionals debate how to measure social media success for dealerships, with participants disagreeing on whether ROI can actually be tracked and whether consumers genuinely use social platforms for car-buying decisions. The consensus that emerges is that social media should be treated like any other marketing channel—measured by concrete conversion metrics (appointments, test drives, sales) rather than vanity metrics like follower counts—while acknowledging that success requires integration with overall marketing strategy and authentic, localized engagement (such as MB Motorsports' weekly detailing specials and humorous content).

Dealers debate whether Make My Deal (a Cox Auto product) is worth adopting, with one user praising its transparency benefits while others compare it unfavorably to previous failed tools like GM's Shop-Click-Drive, citing poor completion rates and customer abandonment. Key concerns include excessive form friction, the risk of surfacing financing limitations that discourage shoppers, and whether the tool actually drives dealership visits or simply duplicates existing contact methods. The consensus leans toward skepticism: these tools may only succeed if they streamline the customer journey rather than force consumers to complete transactions online before visiting the dealership.

A user promotes a J.D. Power infographic listing "Top 10 Things Every Dealers Need to Know" about the automotive retail market, highlighting that 2015 is projected for the second-best sales performance ever, and offers free market-specific data through their PowerDealer tool. Community members call out the post for appearing like promotional spam and request transparency about the poster's identity and affiliation. The thread concludes with confirmation that the actual top 10 list is free and contains useful information, though skepticism about the marketing approach persists.

Dealers debate whether the "optimal" nine photos per vehicle listing truly generates more leads, as claimed in a Ford conference presentation citing a 71% higher submission rate compared to 30-image listings. Multiple forum members challenge this conclusion, with one user's own testing showing no significant difference in lead volume regardless of photo count (8-30 images), and argue that fewer photos may simply prompt more inquiries rather than indicating purchase intent. The consensus leans toward quality over quantity, with the key insight being that the metric measures *lead generation* (inquiries) rather than *sales*, and that shoppers typically view all available photos regardless of count.

Dealers discuss whether Motofuze, an SEO service that populates website subdomains with auto inventory and comparison content to drive organic traffic, is worth implementing. While one dealer reported positive results (increased organic traffic and digital business percentage), critics raise concerns about duplicate content across multiple dealer websites and potential Google penalties, with the original poster ultimately deciding to request performance data before committing.

A dealership Internet Director seeks advice on improving outbound BDC call performance, noting low contact rates and appointment setting despite having leads to work. Respondents recommend implementing manual tracking systems (tick sheets or spreadsheets) to measure calls, contacts, and appointments until a better CRM is available, while emphasizing that management presence in the BDC and effective voicemail/script techniques matter more than the CRM itself. The key insight is that accountability and proper execution of fundamentals—not technology—are the primary drivers of BDC performance, with one expert noting that "your swing" (methodology and execution) matters more than "your clubs" (the CRM).