Websites, SEO, SEM, Display, Social, Marketing

Chad Pelliccioni critiques a YouTube video about Facebook fraud, arguing that declining organic reach isn't due to fake followers but rather Facebook's frequent algorithm updates that have reduced fan base reach from 100% to just 2-5% daily. He contends that dealers can improve performance through legitimate optimization strategies like timing posts strategically and analyzing content performance via Facebook Insights rather than focusing on follower authenticity.

Jason asks for firsthand experience with Opportunity Max, a digital marketing company, but receives no peer recommendations. Cody provides a helpful framework of questions to evaluate any SEO and PPC vendor (blogging/link-building strategy, local SEO approach, landing page optimization), though doesn't address the specific company. The thread yields no concrete information about Opportunity Max's reputation or service quality among DealerRefresh members.

A Chevy dealer skeptical of GM's Cobalt website platform seeks validation from other dealers about whether it generates meaningful leads, particularly through GM's IMR program. Respondents offer minimal substantive feedback, with one dealer expressing enthusiasm but another dismissing compliance-based solutions as inherently mediocre, reflecting the dealer's own resistance to standardized platforms.

Industry professionals share key takeaways from NADA 2014, with consensus that dealers must urgently embrace digital transformation, particularly mobile-responsive websites and apps, to compete in an increasingly connected marketplace. Major trends include rapid adoption of adaptive web design across platforms, growing importance of mobile technology, improved lead categorization systems, and significant consolidation among vendors (notably AutoTrader's acquisitions). The overarching insight is that while digital strategy has become essential for dealer success, many dealerships remain dangerously behind in implementation despite clear market demands.

The thread discusses Google's FTC antitrust investigation, with the primary focus on whether Google unfairly promotes its own properties (like Google Places) in search results at the expense of competitors like Yelp and TripAdvisor. The conversation expands to include Google's $12.5 billion acquisition of Motorola Mobility and its implications for data gathering and competitive practices across Android smartphone manufacturers. The key insight is that Google's strategy of self-promoting its own web properties while controlling the search algorithm raises serious regulatory concerns, ultimately leading to an FTC investigation that participants expect will result in either forced concessions or litigation.

Jeff Kershner opens a discussion about shifting power dynamics in the vehicle listings/classifieds space, questioning which platforms might challenge or disrupt dominant players Cars.com and AutoTrader. The thread explores how organically grown competitors are gaining ground through SEO, SEM, and partnerships, and whether the established giants' brand recognition and OEM backing will be enough to hold their position. It's a forward-looking conversation about where dealer advertising dollars and consumer traffic are headed next.

Google has shut down its car shopping service beta program in the San Francisco Bay Area, marking the company's second failed attempt to break into automotive sales. Industry professionals attribute the failure to dealer reluctance to adopt new platforms without proven success, and suggest Google's internal AdWords team may have blocked the initiative due to concerns about cannibalizing their lucrative PPC advertising business. The consensus is that Google may be regrouping rather than permanently exiting the market, though dealers viewed the service as just another listing platform requiring ongoing management.

Dealers debate the merits of CarWoo, a lead generation platform where customers pay to solicit competitive bids from multiple dealerships simultaneously. While critics like mcampo2501 and ddavis view it as a destructive "bidding war" that devalues brands and wastes time, Scott Salzman from a high-volume NYC Toyota dealer reports generating 5-10 sales monthly and appreciating the qualified, pre-screened leads despite competitive pricing pressure. The thread reflects a divided opinion on whether CarWoo's customer-pays model and transparent competition benefits dealers through easier conversions or harms them through margin compression.

A vendor partner requests that Dealer.com and Purecars implement nofollow tags on external links to Carfax on vehicle detail pages and search results, citing concerns about SEO impact on their client websites. The post is seeking technical implementation without requiring direct contact with account representatives. The thread addresses a specific technical SEO optimization question relevant to dealers using these popular automotive platforms.

Several dealers share negative feedback on Cars.com's 360 SEM program, citing high CPM costs, unclear ad placement across their network, poor click-through rates, and questionable ROI despite hitting guaranteed impression numbers. While the program's co-op eligibility makes it low-risk financially, respondents generally agree there are more effective ways to allocate that $1,500/month budget, such as retargeting and PPC campaigns. One experienced marketer suggests the dealers may not be measuring success properly and emphasizes that display advertising shouldn't be evaluated in isolation but as part of a multi-channel strategy.

Dealers discuss how to evaluate performance on Cars.com and Autotrader, with the key insight that these platforms use different counting methods for VDPs (Vehicle Detail Pages) and SRPs (Search Results Pages), making direct statistical comparisons unreliable. The consensus recommendation is to focus instead on consistent metrics like conversion rates from CTAs within VDPs, SRP-to-VDP ratios, and leads generated rather than trying to benchmark cost-per-VDP across platforms. One respondent emphasizes using third-party tools like VAuto to track performance consistently over time.

A dealer warns against hiring cheap SEO specialists from Craigslist after encountering a scam, but other forum members counter that Craigslist itself isn't the problem—inexperienced hiring is. The consensus advice is to treat any vendor hire seriously by conducting thorough research and vetting, regardless of where you find them, as the platform can be a legitimate source if used correctly.

Craigslist announced a $5 per post fee for dealer vehicle listings starting December 3rd, with ads lasting 30 days and no renewal option. Dealers discuss the impact, with most viewing it positively as a way to reduce spam and low-quality leads, though some question the ROI given the accumulated costs and manpower needed to manage postings. The consensus is that while the fee will eliminate casual spammers and excessive daily reposting, it may also reduce overall traffic and lead quality for dealers who stay on the platform.

A dealer struggling with declining metrics across all channels seeks advice on improving performance without increasing budget, after his owner rejected a SEM proposal. The community debates whether the problem stems from their Cobalt platform limitations, ineffective third-party vendors, or underutilized existing channels—with consensus emerging that meaningful improvements require either reallocating current spending away from underperforming vendors or accepting that truly transformative results require investment.

A dealer's Google Ads account was suspended due to poor ratings on third-party sites (BBB and RipoffReport) despite stellar reviews on Google's own platform, raising concerns about Google's subjective enforcement of policies based on external review sites. The thread debates whether this represents a legitimate crackdown on bad business practices or an overreach by Google into territories outside its own network, with participants unable to find other documented cases of this happening. The consensus suggests this could signal a troubling new trend where Google evaluates advertiser quality based on reputation across uncontrolled third-party platforms rather than its own metrics alone.

• Locked

Automotive industry professionals debate whether digital marketing "experts" advising dealers need technical skills like coding and web development, with the original poster arguing that lack of foundational web knowledge undermines credibility. Responses reveal a divide: some argue technical skills are essential for understanding strategy implementation, while others contend that marketing expertise and business acumen are separate from coding ability, and that proper vetting (references, results-based contracts, and due diligence) matters more than technical credentials. The consensus suggests dealers should be skeptical of unproven consultants, hold vendors accountable with clear success metrics, and recognize that both technical incompetence and overstated credentials are common problems in the automotive marketing space.

A CarGurus VP of Sales shares data-backed principles for dealerships to improve their online reputation through customer reviews, framed around how review quality and quantity directly influence shopper trust and purchase decisions. The post emphasizes that actively managing reviews on platforms like CarGurus is not optional but a competitive necessity. Key insight: dealers who engage with reviews and accumulate them consistently win more consideration from in-market shoppers.

A dealership marketing professional warns against poor timing on automated follow-up campaigns, noting that messages consistently arriving at 4am signal to prospects that they're receiving automated, impersonal outreach rather than genuine sales attention. The key insight is that while automated messaging campaigns can be effective relationship-building tools, dealers undermine their effectiveness by neglecting basic details like send times. The takeaway is that successful automation requires attention to execution details to maintain the appearance of personalized, professional communication.

Internet sales reps debate whether researching prospects online—via Google, social media, and CRM databases—helps close deals faster by revealing personal details like employment, location, and interests. Responses range from enthusiastically endorsing thorough research (especially LinkedIn outreach and competitor analysis) to more cautious approaches focused on CRM lookups and basic data like zip codes and email domains. The key insight is that while strategic research can provide valuable context for personalization, there's a real risk of pre-qualifying leads too aggressively and missing genuine opportunities.

In 2013, CARFAX faced unprecedented challenges including negative media coverage (Automotive News and ABC's 20/20), an antitrust lawsuit, and questions about report accuracy, culminating in parent company RL Polk announcing the sale of the business to IHS for $1.4 billion. The thread captures a pivotal moment when the Vehicle History Report industry leader's business model and practices came under serious scrutiny from regulators, media, and legal action simultaneously.

Dealers are purchasing fake Facebook likes through vendors like Wikimotive at inflated prices ($500/month for 5K likes), despite the same likes being available for $44 online, and the practice provides no real business value while risking Google penalties. The thread criticizes both the unethical vendors promoting these services and dealers wasteful spending on fake engagement metrics that don't translate to actual sales or meaningful customer interaction.

A dealer shares reflections on Price LeBlanc, a Toyota dealer owner from Louisiana who was exceptionally skilled at marketing and dominated his competitive market despite being geographically removed from the main commercial area. The post appears to be setting up a discussion about traditional or unconventional marketing strategies that drove success in a saturated market with multiple competing franchises in close proximity.